Comments on: Requirements to Retire as a Commissioned Officer https://themilitarywallet.com/retire-as-commissioned-officer/ Personal Finance for Military, Veterans, and their Families Wed, 04 Mar 2026 19:29:30 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=7.0 By: Ryan Guina https://themilitarywallet.com/retire-as-commissioned-officer/#comment-188411 Wed, 02 Apr 2025 19:06:47 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=10597#comment-188411 In reply to DEP.

Hello DEP, I don’t believe you can obtain Tricare while you are in the IRR. You will need to work with CHAMPVA customer support to figure out what to do next. You will likely need to elevate this to a supervisor. Best wishes!

]]>
By: DEP https://themilitarywallet.com/retire-as-commissioned-officer/#comment-188159 Mon, 31 Mar 2025 21:21:36 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=10597#comment-188159 Hello Ryan, I have a quick question.
I have transferred to the IRR and at the same time I was deemed 100 P&T.
I was able to get CHAMPVA for my family as well.
However, we got a letter from CHAMPVA stating my family would be disenrolled because “they qualify for Tricare.” I called the DMDC and they confirmed my family qualifies for Tricare (even sent me a letter to this effect). However, when it came time to enroll them…turns out I can’t. So now I am stuck in limbo. Have you ever seen this situation before? I don’t understand it.
Any thoughts?
Thank you in advance.

]]>
By: Ryan Guina https://themilitarywallet.com/retire-as-commissioned-officer/#comment-183384 Tue, 12 Mar 2024 16:25:37 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=10597#comment-183384 In reply to David L McDonald.

David, your situation is unique. I recommend working with a legal expert who specializes in military law. Best wishes!

]]>
By: Ryan Guina https://themilitarywallet.com/retire-as-commissioned-officer/#comment-182223 Thu, 14 Dec 2023 21:35:32 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=10597#comment-182223 In reply to Gian.

Hello Gian,

(1) Yes, you will qualify for a Reserve retirement since you do not have 20 years of Total Active Federal Military Service (TAFMS). In most cases, your retirement pay will start at age 60, along with your healthcare benefits.

(2) My understanding is that a military medical retirement is the same as an active duty retirement, meaning you would receive benefits immediately upon retirement. Military medical retirement is based on your military disability rating, not your VA disability rating. You have to go through the military medical evaluation board, which can be a lengthy process. Your retirement pay would be based on the greater of your military disability rating multiplied by your high-36 base pay, or your years of service multiplied by your high-36 base pay (both are capped at 75% of your high-36). Those who receive medical retirement with 20 years of service and who have a 50% VA disability rating are eligible for Concurrent Retirement and Disability Pay (CRDP).

According to the DFAS website:

To be eligible to receive both military disability retired pay and VA Disability Compensation concurrently, a member who was retired under Chapter 61 for disability must:

  • Have completed 20 years or more of service creditable under 10 U.S.C. § 1405, or 20 years of service computed under 10 U.S.C. § 12732, at the time of the retirement; and
  • Be entitled for any month to both military disability retired pay and VA Disability Compensation; and
  • Have a service-connected disability (or combination of service-connected disabilities) that is rated by the Secretary of Veterans Affairs as not less than 50 percent disabling on the VA schedule for rating disabilities.

Note: A member who was retired under Chapter 61 for disability and who did not have 20 years or more of service creditable under 10 U.S.C. § 1405, or 20 years of service computed under 10 U.S.C. § 12732 at the time of retirement, is not eligible to receive VA Disability Compensation and military disability retired pay concurrently. Therefore, such members are subject to the general rule that requires a dollar-for-dollar waiver of military retired pay in order to receive VA Disability Compensation.

Best wishes!

]]>
By: Gian https://themilitarywallet.com/retire-as-commissioned-officer/#comment-180950 Wed, 12 Jul 2023 18:33:51 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=10597#comment-180950 Hello! I heavily contemplate applying for retirement within the next 2 years or sooner. This will put me at 20 years TIS (15 years active + 5 years reserves). I’m an O3E and in 2 years will also meet my 10th year as an officer.

(1)Will I qualify for reserve/non-regular retirement only since I won’t have 20 years AFS?

(2) If in 2 years & with 20 years TIS, I get medically retired (since it has been brought up to me by multiple providers but I have successfully dodged so far) from active duty with more than 50% disability, will I be entitled to active duty pension and/or CRDP?

I haven’t been able to find the answer to these questions. Neither the Army HR departments nor DFAS have been helpful so far.

Thank you in advance!

]]>
By: Dennis https://themilitarywallet.com/retire-as-commissioned-officer/#comment-179364 Mon, 31 Oct 2022 09:09:28 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=10597#comment-179364 In reply to Doug Nordman.

Doug, Thanks for the useful info. I have a somewhat related question. I’m an active duty officer with 14 years in (> 3 years at my current rank), and no prior enlisted time. Long story short, there’s an enlisted job I want to do and after much research, it is possible for me to resign the commission without a break in service and enlist (active duty Army). If I do that, and then retire at 20 years while enlisted, will my retirement pay and rank be based upon my high-3 officer pay and rank or my enlisted pay and rank?

]]>
By: David L McDonald https://themilitarywallet.com/retire-as-commissioned-officer/#comment-176034 Sat, 28 May 2022 13:11:36 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=10597#comment-176034 Ryan,
What law allows the Army to retire you as an enlisted even though you have 20 AFS of which 10+years were commissioned. I was reverted to enlisted at the end of my 20 AFS. There are settled Board of Correction cases that predate my retirement that support an enlisted at the end of 20+AFS YEARS who retire as OFFICERS
Yet I am on my 3rd Board and have been retired since 2012.

What are your thoughts?

My contact info:
Dave McDonald
Dvdmcdlt@aol.com

]]>
By: jon robinson https://themilitarywallet.com/retire-as-commissioned-officer/#comment-174874 Wed, 09 Mar 2022 17:20:46 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=10597#comment-174874 This in regards to my March 2014 inquiry about which grade I retire at…I am the man who enlisted in the USMC in 1977, with USAF commissioned service (12 years combined active and reserve duty) and who is currently an E6 Army IMA reservist (9 years service) in Korea. I have contacted the personnel people at Fort Knox in regards to my retirement grade question and I have not heard a thing. I was wondering if there is a particular section at USA Reserve Command to address my original question and to get a retirement grade determination? If so, I would appreciate any contact information. Thanks. JON

]]>
By: Doug Nordman https://themilitarywallet.com/retire-as-commissioned-officer/#comment-174878 Wed, 09 Mar 2022 17:20:46 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=10597#comment-174878 In reply to Ann.

Great question, Ann. I’m pretty sure the answer will be “officer”.

The last board allowed most officers to extend until they reached eight years’ commissioned service. A few officers were given waivers by the Secretary to retire as officers. Those special cases didn’t get a followup by the media, but I also didn’t get any unhappy e-mails.

https://the-military-guide.com/army-officers-will-keep-officer-pensions/

My impression is that HRC has learned that it’s less hassle to do the right thing and enable you the opportunity to reach eight years’ commissioned service. (It’s certainly better than dealing with my blog posts, the New York Times investigative journalists, and Congressional inquiries plus legislative initiatives.) If HRC thinks an extension is too long to reach the eight years then you’ll probably get a waiver to retire as an officer.

I’d suggest that you make it easy for the Army to help you get to eight years’ commissioned service. Review your service record with someone who’s seen them at promotion boards. Find an assignment officer at HRC who will review your official record (not a local copy) for any gaps or issues. Make sure your official photo is professional and flawless, because the Army humans on the board will respond to impressive recruiting-poster images of other Army humans. Send in the corrections now (e-mailed or faxed and perhaps by overnight mail), and make sure the corrections get added to your record before the board reviews it.

If you’re worried about being forced to retire, then worry constructively. Attend your service’s transition seminar and think through what you want to do after you retire from the military. Whether you do it on the Army’s schedule or on your schedule, you will eventually retire. It’s always worth investing a little preparation time now, even if you end up staying on active duty for a few more years.

]]>
By: Doug Nordman https://themilitarywallet.com/retire-as-commissioned-officer/#comment-174880 Wed, 09 Mar 2022 17:20:46 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=10597#comment-174880 In reply to 1LT Parker.

Rodney, you’ve certainly researched the issue (thank you!). I see you’ve also found the other posts which discuss the parameters.

It’s difficult to speculate on the reasons for non-promote. It could be age or errors/omissions in a record. It could also have little to do with you and everything to do with downsizing issues and end strength requirements.

If you haven’t already done so, your first step should be to sit down with a JAG to discuss the federal law (with these blog comments) and whether you have any other options. You and the JAG could craft a waiver request to permit you to continue on active duty to reach eight years’ commissioned service due to the critical skills you’re providing in your billet. The point of the request is to force HRC to issue a formal letter response to your waiver request, not to let them discourage you from submitting the request. You want a written response, not just a verbal “We can’t do that”.

You could also contact your elected representatives, because several senators were involved with last year’s OSBs. That tactic might not be popular with HRC or your chain of command, but again you have nothing to lose from starting a Congressional inquiry. Regardless of when or why the “10 years commissioned service” law was passed, only Congress can change it.

I’m not going to hold out false hope. Even if your commission could somehow be backdated to your initial AECP acceptance, you’d still have less than 10 years of commissioned service. Perhaps the best you could hope for would be that your situation calls attention to the need to change the law.

Even if you’re forced into retirement at an enlisted rank, the military may feel that you’ll eventually be “made whole” at the 30-year point. You and the JAG should take a look at 10 U.S. Code § 3964. Here’s the text:
https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/10/3964
Higher grade after 30 years of service: warrant officers and enlisted members
(a) Each retired member of the Army covered by subsection (b) who is retired with less than 30 years of active service is entitled, when his active service plus his service on the retired list totals 30 years, to be advanced on the retired list to the highest grade in which he served on active duty satisfactorily (or, in the case of a member of the National Guard, in which he served on full-time duty satisfactorily), as determined by the Secretary of the Army.

I’m not a lawyer, and I don’t understand whether Section 3964 means that your retirement pay is also recomputed. Your JAG may be able to find the applicable rule in the DoD Financial Management Regulation manual for military retirements:
http://comptroller.defense.gov/Portals/45/documents/fmr/Volume_07b.pdf
Table 1-2 on page 1-33 lists the rules for mandatory retirements, and Rule 6 probably applies to your situation. It doesn’t advise whether your retirement pay is also recomputed when you reach the 30-year point. However section 090401 on page 9-5 says:
Reduction In Pay Due To Advancement
There is no absolute requirement that a member of the Armed Forces be advanced on the
retired list. If advancement and recomputation results in a reduction of retired pay for the member
and is based solely on administrative determination, then, prior to the advancement, the member
should be consulted by the military service and advised that the member’s retired pay would be
reduced if advanced.
A. Enlisted Member. If an enlisted member is, in fact, advanced on the retired
list, then retired pay must be recomputed, even though a reduction of retired pay would result.

To my unqualified interpretation of the FMR, it seems pretty clear that at the 30-year point you could apply to be advanced to O-2 on the retired list– and then you could apply to have your pension recalculated at the O-2 pay scale instead of the E-6 pay scale.

Your former High-Three pay base derived from E-6>22 ($3,724.20) would be switched for a High-Three pay base of O-2E>2 ($5,418.00). Keep in mind that those columns are just the starting points and not the actual dollar amounts. You’d have to calculate the average of the highest 36 months of pay at those ranks. DFAS can help you with the calculation.

Finally, Section 090302 on page 9-4 says you’ll also need an Army determination that you served satisfactorily in your O-2 paygrade. That appears to be handled by an Army Grade Determination Review Board, and it’s up to you and the JAG to ensure that happens during the next few months. You definitely want to get this done while you’re on active duty, because it’ll take months to make it happen after you’re retired.

I know this doesn’t make the situation right, but I hope it helps. Please let me know how it turns out.

]]>