Doug Nordman, Author at The Military Wallet https://themilitarywallet.com/team/doug/ Personal Finance for Military, Veterans, and their Families Mon, 01 Jun 2026 16:24:53 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=7.0 https://themilitarywallet.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/cropped-tmw-favicon-transparent-1-32x32.png Doug Nordman, Author at The Military Wallet https://themilitarywallet.com/team/doug/ 32 32 How Many Years Does It Take To Become Financially Independent? https://themilitarywallet.com/years-become-financially-independent/ https://themilitarywallet.com/years-become-financially-independent/#respond Sun, 08 Aug 2021 17:22:00 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=17691 Your savings rate, not your income, is the most powerful driver of financial independence. See exactly how many years it takes to reach financial independence at savings rates from 15% to 80%, and what military members can do to get there faster.

The post How Many Years Does It Take To Become Financially Independent? appeared first on The Military Wallet.

]]>
Financial independence comes from two factors: having enough assets to cover your expenses. Most people would prefer to focus on the first factor: building assets through a high salary, brilliant investing, or an inheritance. Unfortunately, rapidly raising income to achieve financial independence in a short time is extraordinarily difficult for most people.

The more practical path is to focus on the second factor: reducing expenses. Every person working toward financial independence is eventually forced to choose the values that matter most to them, either working for decades to afford a high-expense lifestyle or reducing spending to minimize their working years.

The right balance is personal. You are being frugal if your values match your spending and you feel good about your retirement goals. You have crossed into deprivation if you are miserable and stressed every day, struggling against material temptations while trying to build enough assets to stop working. The goal is to find the work-life balance that works for you and your family.

How Much Will You Need to Be Financially Independent?

Once you understand the framework, the next question is: how much will you need? For this analysis, we will use the Trinity Study’s 4% safe withdrawal rate as our benchmark.

The Trinity Study assumes you spend 4% of your retirement portfolio during the first year and raise the amount for inflation every succeeding year. Dozens of studies have clustered around safe withdrawal rates of 2% to 6% using various assumptions, but most agree that 4% is a reasonable and widely accepted benchmark.

Note: Some financial planners now suggest a more conservative rate of 3.3% to 3.5%, given current market conditions and longer life expectancies. The 4% rule remains the most widely cited benchmark and a practical starting point for this analysis, but it is worth discussing your specific situation with a fee-only financial planner.

The math result is straightforward:

Assets = Expenses / 0.04 = Expenses × 25

Once your assets are 25 times your annual expenses, you are financially independent and able to retire. Before you can solve this equation, you need to track your expenses and develop a realistic retirement spending budget.

How Long Will It Take to Become Financially Independent?

Once you know how much you need, the next question is how quickly you can get there. Rather than focusing on raising income, which can involve unpredictable promotions and pay raises, let’s focus on what you can control: your savings rate.

Simplifying Assumptions

Before diving into the numbers, here are the assumptions behind the analysis:

  • A constant savings rate, even though military members will have longevity pay raises, promotions, and occasional tax-free combat pay
  • A single income earner, though a working spouse can significantly improve the savings rate
  • Constant expenses, though expenses will generally drop as frugality improves, and deployment expenses can be even lower
  • A conservative rate of return of 5% to 6% per year in a high-equity portfolio, such as TSP index funds with low expenses
  • A safe withdrawal rate of 4%, rising annually for inflation
  • No pension, no Social Security, no Medicare — this calculation assumes you are funding retirement entirely from your own investments and health insurance

The Math Behind Savings Rate and Financial Independence

Let’s start with an extreme case. Jacob Lund Fisker, widely recognized as one of the founders of the FIRE (Financial Independence, Retire Early) movement and author of Early Retirement Extreme, achieved financial independence by saving as much as 80% of his income. That is extreme, but it illustrates the power of a high savings rate.

If you earn $1,000 per year and save 80% — or $800 — your expenses are $200 per year. Achieving assets of 25 times expenses requires $5,000. At $800 per year in savings, the time to financial independence is $5,000 ÷ $800 = 6.25 years. In the real world, those savings would be invested in a balanced portfolio that would compound over time, potentially accelerating the retirement date by a few months.

At the other end of the spectrum, most financial advisors encourage new investors to save at least 15% of their income. A 15% savings rate means your expenses are 85% of your income. Achieving assets of 25 times your expenses at a 15% savings rate, with the benefit of compounding, takes approximately 43 years. That is also roughly the length of a traditional working career from your 20s to your 60s.

The most important insight from these two examples is that savings rate, not income, is the primary driver of financial independence timeline. Compounding over decades makes even modest savings grow significantly, but a high savings rate dramatically shortens the time needed.

Years to Financial Independence by Savings Rate

The following tables show how long it takes to reach financial independence at various savings rates, assuming a 5% or 6% annual return on investments:

At a 5% Annual Return:

Savings Rate %Years to FI
15%43
30%28
40%22
50%17
60%12
70%9
80%6

At a 6% Annual Return:

Savings Rate %Years to FI
15%39
30%26
40%20
50%16
60%12
70%9
80%5.5

A 1% increase in your annual return shaves 2 to 4 years off your timeline at most savings rates, a meaningful difference that reinforces the importance of keeping investment costs low.

What This Means for Military Members

For military members, the numbers are even more favorable than the tables suggest, for three important reasons.

The Military Pension

A 20-year military career is a slam dunk for financial independence when saving starts early. The pension covers a significant percentage of retirement expenses and dramatically reduces the portfolio size needed to cover the rest. If your pension covers 50% of your retirement expenses, you only need to accumulate assets equal to 12.5 times your remaining expenses, not 25 times your full expenses.

The Blended Retirement System

Military members under the Blended Retirement System (BRS) benefit from government-matched contributions of up to 5% of base pay into their TSP, free money that directly boosts their effective savings rate without requiring additional income. For 2026, military members can contribute up to $24,500 annually to their TSP, giving them one of the highest-limit tax-advantaged savings vehicles available to any American worker.

Deployment Income

Deployments to combat zones can dramatically accelerate savings. Tax-free combat pay, reduced living expenses, and the ability to exceed normal TSP contribution limits while deployed all contribute to higher savings rates during deployment years. Even as few as two service obligations, totaling 8 to 12 years, will see significant pay increases as well as high savings rates during deployments.

The Bottom Line for Military Members

More aggressive savings rates of 60% to 70%, especially with a working spouse, can cut the time to financial independence to a decade, even without accounting for pay raises, promotions, or a pension. Three additional factors work in your favor: Social Security, investment returns above the conservative 5% to 6% assumed in the tables, and the ability to adjust your retirement spending if needed.

A conservative retirement budget and the flexibility to play strong financial defense during recessions give military members a significant safety margin to enjoy their retirement years.

The Formula Behind the Numbers

For those who want to run their own calculations, here is the math:

Assets = Expenses × 25

= (Savings rate) × [(1 + compounding rate)^Time – 1] / (compounding rate)

Rearranging the terms:

(1 + compounding rate)^Time = (Expenses × 25 × compounding rate / savings rate) + 1

Taking the natural logarithm of both sides:

Time = ln[(Expenses × 25 × compounding rate / savings rate) + 1] / ln(1 + compounding rate)

You can also use an online compound interest calculator or retirement calculator to run your own numbers based on your specific savings rate and expected return.

Start Building Financial Independence Today

Financial independence is achievable for anyone willing to be intentional about their savings rate. The math is clear: the higher your savings rate, the faster you reach financial independence, and the less you are dependent on investment returns to carry you across the finish line.

For military members, the combination of a pension, TSP matching contributions under BRS, tax-free combat pay, and the discipline that military life instills makes financial independence not just achievable but highly likely for those who start saving early and stay consistent.

The ideal time to start was the first day you received a paycheck. The next best time is today.

The post How Many Years Does It Take To Become Financially Independent? appeared first on The Military Wallet.

]]>
https://themilitarywallet.com/years-become-financially-independent/feed/ 0
Start a Roth IRA For Your Kid https://themilitarywallet.com/start-a-roth-ira-kids/ https://themilitarywallet.com/start-a-roth-ira-kids/#comments Mon, 02 Aug 2021 00:56:00 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=17548 Did you know you can start a Roth IRA for your kids? All they need is earned income— but the definition of earned income is tricky.

The post Start a Roth IRA For Your Kid appeared first on The Military Wallet.

]]>
Key Takeaways
  • Any child with earned income can contribute to a Roth IRA, contributions are limited to the lesser of their earned income or $7,500 in 2026, and the account grows tax-free for decades
  • Parents with a family business can legally employ their children and use that earned income to fund a Roth IRA, but documentation and clean record-keeping are essential to avoid IRS scrutiny
  • A child’s Roth IRA is not counted in college aid financial aid calculations, making it a more flexible savings tool than a 529 account for families who want to preserve financial aid eligibility

Yes, you can start a Roth IRA for your child, even if they’re a baby! All they need is earned income— but the definition of earned income is tricky. Here’s how to navigate that minefield.

Before I get into the details and how you can do the same for your kid, let me address two very common concerns:

  1. All of this is perfectly legal. Like any other tax planning, starting your kid’s Roth IRA will only trigger an IRS audit if you get greedy.
  2. The federal government and the college financial aid offices will not penalize your family or your child for having a Roth IRA. The reality is that you’re “penalized” even more for putting assets into a 529 account or a kid’s trust– although those are good tools too.

How to Open a Roth IRA for Your Child

Starting a Roth IRA for your kid is straightforward if they have W-2 or 1099 income. Earned income can come from just about any source and at any age, including babies and toddlers who are paid by agencies as photo models.

Kids with W-2 or 1099 income may also need to file an income tax return. IRS Publication 929 lists the requirements for filing a child’s tax return. They might not need to pay taxes on their income, but filing a return is by far the easiest way to document earned income for a Roth IRA contribution, and it’s a powerful teachable moment for kids to learn about paying income taxes.

IRS Publication 15 states that parents who pay their children under 21 as “family employees” don’t even need to issue W-2s or 1099s. Keeping simple payment records in a notebook or software is sufficient if necessary.

One practical challenge is finding an investment firm that will sub-custody a Roth IRA for a minor. Not all firms offer custodial Roth IRAs, so it’s worth researching options before getting started. Vanguard and Fidelity are commonly used options for custodial accounts.

Can I Hire My Kids in My Business?

The easiest way for kids to earn an income is to employ them in your family business if you have one, and that’s generally exempt from self-employment tax. Check with your CPA for specifics. Common kid jobs in a family business include:

  • Rolling change from coin-operated laundry machines.
  • Cleaning the rental property and mowing its yard.
  • Baby models ($25/hour) for photos in your blog posts or product sales.
  • Partners on YouTube videos.

There are two key points for paying kids in the family business:

  1. Document their labor. This is as simple as a notebook with date, task, hours worked, and pay. That’s good enough for the IRS.
  2. Be careful with your business deductions. If you take questionable deductions for your kid’s labor, the IRS matching computers may send a query letter about the business. One family lost a Tax Court case over their business deductions, and the IRS went after parts of the kids’ Roth IRA contributions because some of the family business deductions crossed the line from aggressive accounting into illegal territory. The lesson: keep clean, contemporaneous records, and don’t mix business jobs with household chores.

You do not need to issue a W-2 or 1099 to document your kids income for a Roth IRA contribution. A simple work log recording what they did, when they worked, and what they were paid is sufficient. The simpler your record-keeping, the more likely you are to do it consistently and correctly.

How Kids Can Earn Income Without a Family Business

Kid entrepreneurs can contribute to their Roth IRA when they have self-employment income from yard care, dog walking, babysitting, or similar work. However, they may also have to pay self-employment taxes if their net income is at least $400. A young entrepreneur will likely need help from a parent or accountant to take every legitimate deduction against their gross income. They can still contribute all of their earned income to their Roth IRA, up to the annual contribution limits.

Teens can also earn income by recording videos, running YouTube channels, or starting other online businesses. When they turn 18, they can do it in their own name without needing a family business structure.

Can I Pay My Kids for Jobs Around the House?

Maybe, but it’s a gray area. Your kids have to be paid for a job you would outsource to any other person, not for typical family chores. Here are some examples:

  • Paid to paint the house, mow the lawn, or wash the car – likely earned income, especially if you’ve always hired these out
  • Paid to clean a kitchen or bedroom in an investment rental property between tenants – earned income
  • Paid to make their own bed or clean their own room – not earned income
  • Paid to clean the kitchen in your primary residence – not earned income

If there’s no family business, the IRS may disagree that your payments to your kids qualify as earned income. When in doubt, consult your accountant before contributing to the Roth IRA.

How to Motivate Your Child to Contribute to Their Roth IRA

This is a teachable moment about choosing between immediate gratification and investing for the future. No matter what your kid decides, it’s their earned income, and the conversation itself is valuable.

One approach is to use gifting as an incentive. Per the tax code, anyone can gift anyone else up to $19,000 in 2026 with zero tax due and no paperwork. Your kid could contribute their earned income to their Roth IRA, the lesser of their earned income or $7,500 in 2026, and you could then gift them an amount to replace what they contributed, motivating them to keep saving.

Showing kids a spreadsheet of the difference between contributing to a Roth IRA at age 12 versus age 22 can also be a powerful motivator. The compound math behind a 10-year head start is compelling for financially curious kids.

Can a Child’s Roth IRA Be Used for College?

A Roth IRA can also help save for college and is more flexible than a 529 plan if your child decides not to attend college. Contributions to a Roth IRA can be withdrawn at any time for any reason without additional tax or penalties, and Roth IRA earnings can be withdrawn penalty-free for qualified educational expenses.

However, a student’s withdrawals from an IRA may be treated as income that counts against their financial aid for the following year. It’s generally better to avoid using the Roth IRA for college expenses and to keep contributing to it instead.

A teen’s Roth IRA will not affect the family’s eligibility for financial aid, retirement accounts are not included in the financial aid calculation, and students’ Roth IRA assets are not assessed as part of their expected financial contribution.

Building on Your Child’s Roth IRA After College

One of the first financial priorities for a college graduate is setting up an emergency fund. Instead of leaving that emergency fund in a checking account or savings account, they can contribute it to their Roth IRA. Since contributions can be withdrawn at any time for any reason, they can put the money to work in a bond fund or blue-chip stock fund and still have access to it in an emergency.

The earlier a child starts their Roth IRA, the greater the long-term benefit. A Roth IRA started in childhood lays a strong foundation for reaching financial independence at a younger age than most people.

The post Start a Roth IRA For Your Kid appeared first on The Military Wallet.

]]>
https://themilitarywallet.com/start-a-roth-ira-kids/feed/ 6
The Reserve Component Survivor Benefit Plan https://themilitarywallet.com/the-reserve-component-survivor-benefit-plan/ https://themilitarywallet.com/the-reserve-component-survivor-benefit-plan/#comments Thu, 15 Jul 2021 21:26:00 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=17524 The Reserve Component Survivor Benefit Plan can provide a lifetime of income for your survivors should you predecease them. But it may come with a high price.

The post The Reserve Component Survivor Benefit Plan appeared first on The Military Wallet.

]]>
key Takeaways
  • The RCSBP provides Reserve and Guard members with survivor benefit coverage during the “gray area” years before 60, meaning your beneficiaries are protected even if you pass away before your pension begins.
  • You must make your RCSBP election within 90 days of receiving your 20-Year Letter. If no election is made, you are automatically enrolled in Option C, which provides immediate coverage.
  • RCSBP premiums stop after 30 years of payments and age 70, at which point coverage becomes paid-up for life, making it one of the most cost-effective long-term survivor benefit options available to Reserve and Guard members.

The Survivor Benefit Plan is designed to provide survivors of deceased military retirees with a portion of the retiree’s pension. For members of the Reserve and National Guard, a similar program called the Reserve Component Survivor Benefit Plan (RCSBP) offers comparable protections with some key differences that reflect the unique nature of reserve service.

This guide covers everything you need to know about the RCSBP, including eligibility, coverage options, costs, and how it compares to the standard Survivor Benefit Plan. Whether you are currently serving in a Reserve Component or approaching retirement, understanding the RCSBP is an important part of planning for your family’s financial future.

What is the Reserve Component Survivor Benefit Plan?

The Reserve Component Survivor Benefit Plan (RCSBP) enables people who served in the Reserve Components to leave their heirs a benefit called an annuity.

An annuity is a monthly payment that continues to your beneficiary for the rest of their life after you pass away. The monthly payment is a percentage of your retired pay and depends on the election you make when you enroll in RCSBP.

The SBP was enacted by Congress in 1972, and the Reserve Component SBP was added in 1978. The RCSBP sells insurance to Reserves/Guards who have applied for retirement but are not yet age 60 (“gray area”). Once they reach age 60, their RCSBP is the same program as the SBP, but with slightly different premiums to cover a portion of the costs incurred in the years before age 60. Congress pays about 40% of the program, and the rest is covered by the retirees’ premiums paid to the SBP and the RCSBP.

Although only about 75% of active duty retirees buy the SBP annuity, over 90% of retiring Reserve/Guard members enroll in the RCSBP. The difference appears to be the inexpensive insurance coverage during the “gray area” years before age 60, and the fact that premiums aren’t due until age 60.

Note: Reserve and Guard members who serve on qualifying active duty after January 28, 2008 may be eligible to reduce their retirement age below 60. Each 90-day period of qualifying active service reduces the retirement age by three months, to a minimum age of 50. Learn more about National Guard and Reserve early retirement age.

The Reserve Component Survivor Benefit Plan (RCSBP) is like the Survivor Benefit Plan (SBP) annuity, covering non-reserve components of the armed services. However, there are several differences in eligibility between the RCSBP and SBP, including coverage and costs, that reflect the unique nature of reserve service.

RCSBP is another incentive offered by the Department of Defense to encourage Reserve/Guard to retire, awaiting pay instead of resigning pending retirement. When Reserve/Guard members reach 20 years of qualifying service, they can either apply for retirement (awaiting pension at age 60) or resign from the Reserve/Guard until their pension starts (at age 60).

For the DoD, the difference is that “retired awaiting pay” means the member can be recalled in the event of a full mobilization of the armed forces. (Even though recalling a retiree is highly unlikely.) There are several financial reasons to retire rather than resign, and an additional reason is that Reserve/Guard members who have “retired awaiting pay” can buy SBP coverage for their beneficiaries.

Another reason to buy RCSBP coverage is that it starts as soon as the Reserve/Guard member retires, rather than at age 60. It’s possible to reach 20 years of qualifying service in your late 30s and wait over two decades before drawing the pension at age 60. If SBP is elected at the time of applying for retirement, then the Reserve/Guard member has SBP coverage for that entire time before age 60. By law, upon retirement, the member is automatically enrolled in full coverage. The decision to reduce or decline coverage is actually made by the spouse.

If the retiree dies prematurely, then one of their survivor’s options would be to receive up to 55% of their pension immediately instead of waiting until they would have been age 60. The Reserve/Guard member doesn’t actually have to pay the SBP premiums for that coverage until their pension starts. In other words, Reserve/Guard members who have “retired awaiting pay” can have over two decades of “free” insurance coverage before they even start drawing their pension.

Better still, at age 62 (after paying two years of SBP premiums) they can either continue their SBP coverage or cancel it.

The RCSBP has three options:

  • A: Decline coverage until age 60 and revisit the decision then.
  • B: Deferred Coverage – If you die before age 60, an RCSBP annuity begins paying out on what would have been your 60th birthday.
  • C: Immediate Coverage – The RCSBP annuity would begin on the day after your death, even before age 60. This is the default option.

The annuity is based on the retirement pay earned by you. Your retirement pay cannot continue after your death; only you may draw the retirement pay you earned. Under the RCSBP, if you have 20 qualifying years of service, you can designate to whom you want the annuity to be paid.

Who Can Be Named as an RCSBP Beneficiary?

The designee(s) may be your:

  • Spouse – The widow or widower of the deceased service member who was married to the service member at the time of his or her death and who:
    • Was married to the service member for at least one year prior to the service member’s death
    • Was married to the service member at the time of RCSBP
    • Is the parent of a child born after the RCSBP election was made.
  • Former spouse – The service member may elect former spouse SBP coverage within one year of the divorce if the service member previously covered that person as Spouse.
  • Children – The child of the deceased service member is eligible for coverage when he/she is
    • Single and under the age of 18, or
    • Between the ages of 18 and 22, and enrolled in a full-time course of study or training in a recognized educational institution, or
    • Incapable of self-support due to mental or physical disability that existed before the child’s 18th birthday or was incurred before age 22 while the child was engaged in a full-time course of study or training.
  • Person with an insurable interest in the service member – A person who has a logical and/or lawful reason to expect financial benefit from the continued life of the service member. The expectation is founded on the relationship between the parties (financial, blood, marriage, or mutual affection).

NOTE: If you have received a 15-year letter authorizing early retirement at age 60, you are also offered this benefit.

The RCSBP’s enhanced “free” gray-area coverage comes at a price: the premiums are calculated at a slightly higher rate than the conventional SBP’s 6.5%. The premiums are determined from data tables and fact sheets provided when the Reserve/Guard member receives their notice of eligibility for retirement (20 good years). Members can also estimate their payments from an RCSBP calculator.

Spouses can elect the full amount of coverage (55% of the Reserve/Guard pension) or smaller amounts. The decision should be based on the survivor’s projected spending or to ensure the ability to pay off a large expense, such as a mortgage.

Which Reserve Components Are Eligible for the RCSBP?

The RCSBP is available to members of the following retired Reserve Components:

  • The Army National Guard of the United States
  • The Army Reserve
  • The Navy Reserve
  • The Marine Corps Reserve
  • The Air National Guard of the United States
  • The Air Force Reserve

How to Enroll in the RCSBP

Enrollment in the RCSBP is triggered when you receive your 20-Year Letter, the official notice of eligibility for retirement pay at age 60. You must make your RCSBP election within 90 days of receiving this letter. If you do not make an election within that window, you will be automatically enrolled in Option C, which provides immediate coverage for your beneficiaries.

Your election is made on DD Form 2656-5, the Reserve Component Survivor Benefit Plan Election Certificate. Once your election is made, it is generally irrevocable, so it is important to carefully consider your options before submitting the form. If you are married at the time of your election, your spouse must also sign the form acknowledging the coverage decision.

How Much Does the RCSBP Cost?

You pay the cost of participation in the RCSBP when you begin receiving retired pay at age 60. Upon your death, the RC cost is transferred to the annuitant. Once you make an election, you may not cancel your participation in RCSBP.

Costs to participate vary and are based on your age and your annuitant’s age at the time of the election, the option you select, the base amount you select, and your retired pay.

Here’s how you can approximate your RCSBP costs.

Compute your retired pay using the retired pay formula:

[(Your total retirement points / 360) x 0.025] x monthly active duty pay for your rank and years of service = your monthly gross retired pay

RCSBP is comprised of two costs: the base SBP premium cost that all active and reserve service members pay (called the BASE cost); and the RC cost which is the cost for carrying your annuity without payment until you reach age 60.

Your BASE cost is: 2.5% of the first $1,056 (threshold amount) of your retired pay ($26.40), plus 10% of all remaining retired pay over $1,056, if your projected retired pay will be $2,262.86 or less per month.

If your retirement pay is projected to exceed $2,262.86 per month, the BASE cost will be 6.5% of that amount. For example, if you project that your monthly retirement pay will be $3,000, then your monthly BASE cost would be $3,000 x 0.065 = $195.00

The second part of the RCSBP cost is based on your monthly retired pay, your age, and the age(s) of your annuitant(s) at the time you make the election. Refer to the SBP Fact Sheet provided with your Notification of Eligibility (20-Year Letter) for Retired Pay at Age 60 for more information.

It is also worth noting that RCSBP premiums are not required indefinitely. Once you have paid premiums for 30 years and have reached age 70, your coverage becomes paid-up, meaning premiums stop, but your beneficiary’s coverage continues for life. This paid-up provision is one of the most significant long-term advantages of the RCSBP over private insurance alternatives.

How Much Does the RCSBP Pay?

RCSBP pays designated annuitants 55 percent of their retired pay. Several variables apply to your specific situation and affect the amount you receive. The SBP cost factors displayed are based on spouse-only coverage.

It is also worth noting that as of January 1, 2023, the SBP-DIC offset has been fully eliminated. Surviving spouses who qualify for both SBP and VA Dependency and Indemnity Compensation (DIC) now receive full payments from both programs.

The post The Reserve Component Survivor Benefit Plan appeared first on The Military Wallet.

]]>
https://themilitarywallet.com/the-reserve-component-survivor-benefit-plan/feed/ 12
How to Maximize TSP Contributions in a Combat Zone https://themilitarywallet.com/maximizing-your-thrift-savings-plan-contributions-in-a-combat-zone/ https://themilitarywallet.com/maximizing-your-thrift-savings-plan-contributions-in-a-combat-zone/#comments Sat, 13 Nov 2021 02:17:00 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=17490 You can contribute up to $72,000 to your Thrift Savings Plan (TSP) while serving in a combat zone. Discover how to make the most of your TSP contributions during deployment.

The post How to Maximize TSP Contributions in a Combat Zone appeared first on The Military Wallet.

]]>
Expert Reviewed by: Mike Hunsberger, ChFC®, CFP®, CCFC, MQFP, Next Mission Financial Planning

Since many military families have already learned the basics of contributing to the Thrift Savings Plan (TSP), we’re receiving numerous questions about maximizing those contributions during deployments to combat zones.

Not only is military pay exempt from federal and state taxes for servicemembers deployed in a combat zone, but servicemembers are also eligible for much higher contributions to the TSP. 

I’ll get into the gory details during this post, but for now, I’ll mention that the annual additions limit of the tax code is $72,000 for the year 2026. That limit applies even when you’re not in the combat zone for the entire year! Additionally, individuals aged 50 and above can contribute an additional $8,000.

In this article, we’ll run through some examples to show you how to maximize your contributions while in a combat zone and what you need to keep in mind to make sure you don’t max out your contributions and lose out on DoD matching contributions. 

Note: The last sentence means that your higher limits are still available if your deployment is less than a full calendar year.

Key Points

  • The Thrift Savings Plan (TSP) is a retirement savings and investment plan designed specifically for military and civil service members. Military members covered by the  Blended Retirement System (BRS) receive agency and service matching contributions from the Department of Defense (DoD).
  • The TSP has contribution limits set annually by the IRS, which allow members to contribute up to a specific dollar amount each year. One of the advantages that military members have, in particular, is the ability to contribute far more than the annual limit while deployed in a combat (tax-free) zone. 
  • For 2026, the limit is $24,500 for regular contributions, with an additional catch-up contribution limit of $8,000 for those over 50. However, eligible military members can contribute up to the $72,000 maximum Annual Contribution Limit while in a combat zone. 
  • I’ve created a free spreadsheet so you can see how this works with your pay. See the example below to see it in action.

Taxes on TSP Contributions: Normal vs. Combat Zone Rules

Under normal circumstances, contributions to a Traditional TSP are made with pre-tax dollars, meaning you defer paying taxes until you withdraw the funds. The contributions grow tax-deferred, but you will pay ordinary income tax on both the contributions and earnings when you withdraw them.

For a Roth TSP, contributions are made with post-tax dollars, so while you pay taxes upfront, both your contributions and their earnings can be withdrawn tax-free if the distribution is qualified.

For servicemembers in a combat zone, the tax treatment of TSP contributions changes significantly. Contributions made to a Traditional TSP while in a combat zone are tax-exempt, meaning you don’t pay taxes on those contributions. However, the earnings on these contributions grow tax-deferred and will be taxed as ordinary income upon withdrawal. The original tax-exempt contributions can be withdrawn tax-free.

With a Roth TSP, contributions made in a combat zone are also tax-exempt, and both the contributions and their earnings can be withdrawn tax-free, provided the distribution is qualified.

2026 Combat Zone TSP Contribution Limits

  • Roth TSP contributions before, during, and after your time in a tax-exempt zone count toward the elective deferral limit ($24,500).
  • Traditional TSP contributions made before or after being in a tax-exempt zone count toward the elective deferral limit ($24,500).
  • Traditional TSP contributions made while in a tax-exempt (combat) zone are listed as “Traditional tax-exempt contributions” and only count toward the annual addition limit ($72,000).
  • DoD matching contributions count toward the annual addition limit ($72,000).

Catch-up contributions are allowed for members age 50 or older ($8,000).

What Are TSP Annual Contribution Limits?

IRS rules allow military members to contribute up to the annual addition limit of $72,000 when serving in a tax-exempt zone.

I’ll also answer the question that most of you are thinking about right now:

Hey Nords, I just checked my Leave and Earnings Statement, and, golly dude, I’m not getting paid $72K this *year*– let alone during this deployment. I have expenses, too. Where the heck are people getting the money for this?!?”

The TSP annual addition limit is the maximum total amount that can be contributed to a participant’s account in a given year from all sources, including contributions from the participant and matching contributions from the DoD.

In other words, that $72,000 limit includes your DoD BRS agency/matching contributions. You’re not actually contributing all of that limit from your pay. 

If you’re not part of the Blended Retirement System, you don’t receive matching contributions from the government, so this number won’t apply to you. But you can still personally contribute up to your elective deferral limit of $24,500.

Finally, you’ll be surprised at how much the DoD and the IRS will help you reach that goal, and this post includes the links to ensure it applies to you.

Why Would Anyone Contribute $72,000 Per Year to Their TSP?

Short answer: The TSP has some of the world’s largest passively managed index funds with some of the world’s lowest expense ratios. You can get tax-deferred compounding and tax-free withdrawals depending on how you contribute. 

You don’t even have to wait until age 59.5 to tap your TSP.

The TSP is one of several investing answers, but it should be a big part of every military family’s asset allocation plan. (Some might decide it’s the best part.) In the combat zone, you’re putting tax-free pay into the TSP. This offers a huge compounding advantage and means you have more money to contribute to your TSP account instead of “contributing” it to the U.S. Treasury’s income-tax fund via withholding and tax returns.

Finally (stay with me here), combat deployments are not exactly fun. (Not even submarine deployments.) We personal finance bloggers talk boldly about frugality versus deprivation and work-life balance, but let’s not kid ourselves: this deployment will be more work than life and a lot more deprivation. As long as you’re embracing the suck, you can still extract some value from the pain by investing as much as possible toward your financial independence life goal.

For a few of us, maximizing TSP contributions during a deployment is a great way to minimize lifestyle expansion after a deployment. Yeah, you worked hard, and you deserve a nice reward. Instead of a dollar-gobbling depreciating pile of a pickup truck, how about sleeping better at night knowing you’re on track for financial independence? Sure, give yourself a small victory lap party, but avoid the temptation of the hedonic treadmill by putting most of that money where it’s hard to frit away.

No worries, this post includes a detailed year-round example. I also have a spreadsheet for you to edit with your own numbers.

Next question: Where are these combat zones located?

Surprisingly, they don’t all involve actual combat. I hope.

Which Combat Zones Are Eligible?

The DoD and the Internal Revenue Service work with Congress to define combat zones. Here’s the text straight from the IRS press release:

The term ‘combat zone(s)’ is a general term used on IRS.gov and includes all of the following hostile areas where military may serve: actual combat areas, direct combat support areas, and contingency operations areas.”

I was surprised to learn that Djibouti, the Philippines, and even the Sinai Peninsula are eligible for combat zone benefits. The distinction is not whether you’re shooting but rather whether you could be shooting or whether you’re helping other people shoot. 

According to the IRS, if you are receiving imminent danger pay or hostile fire pay and your service falls under one of the three scenarios, then you are eligible for Combat Zone pay rules:

  1. Service in an active combat area as designated by Executive Order, and receive special pay for duty subject to hostile fire or imminent danger as certified by DoD.
  2. Service in a support area as designated by DoD in direct sustainment of military operations in the combat zone, and receive special pay for duty subject to hostile fire or imminent danger as certified by DoD.
  3. Service in a contingency operation as designated by DoD, and receive special pay for duty subject to hostile fire or imminent danger as certified by DoD.

Read the fine print in the IRS notice, but if you’re getting that pay on deployment, then you’re probably eligible for the tax code’s annual additions limit to your TSP.

How to Reach The Combat Zone TSP Annual Additions Limit

1. Spread Out Your Contributions

Because the annual addition limit ($72,000) includes government matching contributions, you must dial back your contributions to allow for DoD’s 5% match of your base pay. 

To make things even more complicated for BRS members, you’ll need to spread your 5% contributions across all 12 months of the calendar year, or you’ll miss some of the match. We touch on this more in the section below.

2. Adjust Your Contribution Amount in MyPay

Here’s another good deal: by the definition of the combat zone, you’re getting more special pay (at least hostile fire or imminent danger pay). You lived without that money when you were in the U.S., and you can probably live without spending it in a combat zone. 

Since it’s tax-free, you can set your contribution percentage to 100% to contribute all of it to the TSP. You can do this through MyPay or TSP.gov. 

3. See If You’re Eligible for Bonus Pay

Some of you have planned for the next good deal: bonus money. I am not a lawyer or a CPA or a CFP, and you’ll have to read your bonus contracts very carefully to make sure you’re eligible, but here’s the link: if you sign a bonus contract in a combat zone eligible for CZTE pay, then it’s not taxable.

Let’s be clear: I would not volunteer to re-enlist or sign a bonus contract in a combat zone just for the tax-free pay. (Yes, I get reader questions about how to volunteer for this.) I would not even do it to pay off student loans or consumer debt. Yet if you’re planning to obligate the service anyway, or if you’re eligible to sign up for the BRS Continuation Pay bonus between 8-12 years of service, then as long as you’re in the combat zone, you might as well make the most of your pay advantages.

Suddenly, that annual addition limit might be within your reach.

4. Contribute More Money After You Leave the Combat Zone

Here’s another fine-print point that the BRS has highlighted: these annual addition limits are per calendar year, not just for the duration of deployment. When you deploy to a combat zone, you’re eligible for the annual additions limit for the rest of the calendar year. You’re contributing tax-free pay when you’re in the combat zone, yet you can continue to contribute taxable pay to the TSP after you leave the combat zone.

5. Sell Investments From Your Taxable Accounts

Here’s another method that readers have shared with me: sell some investments from your taxable accounts. 

Here’s the theory: You’d raise your TSP contributions as high as possible. Meanwhile, you’d sell some of your investments in taxable accounts and use that money for living expenses. The net result? You’ve shifted a huge amount of money to the TSP and avoided a whole bunch of capital gains taxes.

This is possible because your combat-zone income is tax-free, so your taxable income for the year is very low. Additionally, when you’re in a low-income tax bracket, your tax rate on long-term capital gains is zero. 

You’ll want to seek professional tax advice from a CFP or a CPA, but this can save you a lot on capital-gains taxes.

6. Contribute Money From a Loan 

One more idea, although it borders on irresponsibility: if you’re a junior officer who’s taken out a career starter loan during college, you can ideally maximize your TSP contributions and live off the balance of that loan. You’d essentially be borrowing money at 1%-2% per year to invest in the TSP and then paying it back over a longer term. This is extraordinarily risky (high volatility, loss of principle, leveraged debt) but potentially profitable over a decade or longer.

During my research for this post, I learned that you may even be able to contribute to last year’s IRA. Seek professional advice from a CFP or a CPA before you do this.

Let’s cover some important exceptions to meeting the annual additions limit before we get to the examples.

Combat Zone Annual Addition Limit Exceptions

There are a couple of catches to maximizing your combat zone contributions, and after I published this post, it took me a few more e-mails with the TSP to confirm them:

  1. You can not exceed $24,500 in contributions to the Roth TSP at any time during the calendar year. 
  2. When you return home, any further contributions for the rest of the year are subject to the elective deferral limits. 
  3. If your traditional TSP account has already exceeded $24,500 in contributions during the calendar year, you can’t contribute more taxable pay to it.

[See the bottom of this post for the verbatim details of the TSP staff’s interpretation of the tax law.]

The Roth TSP Annual Contribution Limit is Still $24,500 In the Combat Zone

Even when you’re eligible for the higher annual additions limit, Roth TSP contributions still count toward the elective deferral limit. 

Here’s that crucial fine print:

“Tax-exempt contributions made to the traditional balance of a uniformed services account while deployed to a designated combat zone do not count toward the tax code’s elective deferral limit. However, any Roth TSP contributions are subject to the Internal Revenue Code limit even if they are contributed from tax-exempt pay.”

When you’re contributing to your Roth TSP (and you should), you must stay below the Internal Revenue Code limit ($24,500) until December’s contribution. 

This means that your overall annual additions limit will stay just under the elective deferral limit in the Roth TSP (with your last contribution of the year coming in December), and the rest of your contributions will go into the traditional TSP. 

Of course, the DoD BRS agency/match contributions are always going into your traditional TSP (see paragraph 7.b.(12) of that link), so between you and DoD, you’ll end up with the rest of your contributions in your traditional TSP account.When your Roth TSP contributions hit $24,500, no matter where you are or when it is during the year, the TSP computer system will cut you off. Any excess contributions from your pay will be used to reach the limit, but the TSP will kick the rest of the excess back to DFAS. Even worse, the TSP will shut you down at the elective deferral limit ($24,500) and lock you out of contributions for the rest of the calendar year. Which is why you need to leave room for monthly contributions.

BRS Members Should Leave Room For Monthly Contributions To The Roth TSP

The TSP agency has confirmed that when you’re home from the combat zone, you can only contribute to your traditional TSP up to the elective deferral limit. 

That means if you contribute more than the elective deferral limit to your traditional TSP while in the combat zone when you get home, the TSP computers will lock out any further contributions.

If you’re locked out of TSP contributions before the end of the year, you will lose your DoD BRS matching contributions for the rest of the year.

The solution: When setting up your plan for the year of TSP contributions, start by contributing 5% of your monthly base pay to the Roth TSP. That ensures you’ll have 12 months of Roth TSP contributions and 12 months of DoD BRS matching contributions.

BRS Member Example

Note: The following example was initially published in 2018. For consistency, we have left these numbers as they were in the example provided by correspondence with TSP officials. You will need to update this example with your current situation to maximize your contributions.

This example comes from a series of e-mails with the Federal Retirement Thrift Investment Board (FRTIB), the government agency that runs the TSP, and the DoD BRS office.

The DoD BRS office also asked me to pass this on:

“Individual service members who are impacted by this should contact the TSP call center or a tax adviser for guidance on the impacts of IRS regulations on their contributions.”

Please feel free to refer to this post with the DoD BRS office, DFAS, the TSP, and your pay/personnel office. This example is how the system is supposed to work.

Here’s a scenario for a servicemember who:

  1. Opted into the Blended Retirement System or is now covered by default.
  2. Contributes at least 5% to their TSP every month (for the full DoD matching contributions).
  3. Deploys to a combat zone to receive combat zone tax-exempt pay.
  4. Their deployment is from March to September 2018, and they’re back home on 1 October 2018.

Here’s the FRTIB response, edited for easier blog post reading:

I think there are many ways that a service member can do this, and I’ll give an example.

Disclaimer: This is not advice but merely an example of one service member contributing while in a combat zone.

Assumptions:

  1. A servicemember makes $48,000/year in basic pay and receives a $30,000 retention bonus while in a combat zone.
  2. The elective deferral limit is $18,500, and the annual additions limit is $55,000.

Using these numbers, if the service member contributes 5% in January-February and 5% again in October-December, they will have contributed $200 per month of their own money and received agency/matching 5% of $200 per month.

If that happens, the service member will have contributed $1,000 towards the elective deferral limit (their own contributions) and $2,000 towards the annual additions limit (their own contributions and employer contributions).

That leaves seven months in the combat zone to figure out how to contribute.

In this exact scenario, it likely makes sense to contribute to Roth up to the elective deferral limit less contributions made in January-February and October-December because those contributions will be tax-free going in and tax-free coming out so long as all of the other tax requirements are met.

In that case, there is $17,500 left towards the elective deferral limit ($18,500 minus the $1,000 contributed in the months while not in a combat zone). That divided over seven months is $2,500 per month of which there will be an additional agency/matching 5% contribution of $1,400.

This brings the total contribution to the TSP to $20,900 meaning the service member can contribute an additional $34,100 of tax-exempt money to their traditional account. That amount over a seven month period is $4,871 per month.

These amounts will allow for both the elective deferral and annual additions limit to be reached and the maximum amount of matching to be reached (5% of $48,000).

Of course, this service member could adjust the numbers to increase the contributions while not in a combat zone and decrease the amount while in a combat zone.

However, if the service member reaches the elective deferral limit before they leave the combat zone, they will not be permitted to make any contributions when they return.

Use a Spreadsheet to Model Your Contributions

As you may have concluded by now, that has to be added to a spreadsheet to be clearly understood.

Here’s the link to that Google Sheet for maximizing BRS contributions to the Thrift Savings Plan from a combat zone.

Please note that to edit this spreadsheet, you’ll have to copy it (“File | Download as…”) to your device and then edit your copy.

What If You’re Still In The Legacy High 3 Pension System?

If you’re in the High 3 pension, the rules are still the same for your combat zone contributions; only you don’t have to worry about DoD’s BRS agency or matching contributions.

Just, remember to stay below the Roth TSP contribution limit, as mentioned in the BRS section. 

[Reader question:

“Hello, I read your article about maximizing TSP in a combat zone. I ran into an issue earlier in 2018. Before deploying in June, I had contributed about $18,300 to traditional TSP and $200 to Roth. When I arrived I was unable to make any more contributions to Roth, but I was able to contribute to Traditional. Why is this?”

My response:

If you contributed $18,500 to the TSP before deploying, you’d already hit the elective deferral limit ($18,500 in 2018) before arriving in the combat zone. The TSP computers and DFAS would have locked you out of further contributions.

Now that you’re deployed, neither the TSP nor DFAS would have automatically restarted your contributions. Perhaps someone from your pay office (or DFAS) noted your combat-zone status and restarted the contributions. Since you had already reached your annual contribution limit (and they had to turn it back on) for some reason the TSP system wouldn’t accept new contributions to the Roth TSP.

I’m sorry this happened. Servicemembers who’ve opted into the new Blended Retirement System or are now covered by it by default are advised not to front-load their TSP contributions so that they can receive the monthly DoD BRS match all year long. This appears to be a similar issue with the TSP computer system.

Note For Servicemembers 50 and Up

If you’re 50 or older, you can include a $8,000/year “catch-up” contribution.

You active-duty folks shouldn’t smirk at this clarification– you’d be surprised how many Reserve and National Guard servicemembers are in their 50s. That should tell you something about how challenging & fulfilling the Reserve & Guard can be if you’re feeling a little burned-out on active duty.

A Friendly Little Note From The IRS

[19 December 2018 update: see a sample IRS letter a few paragraphs below, at the end of this section.]

Several servicemembers (and their frustrated spouses) have mentioned receiving IRS letters asking the servicemember to verify their deployment to a combat zone. One family was still receiving IRS letters about a 2016 deployment while the servicemember was deployed again in late 2017.

This letter is automatically generated by an IRS computer, which tries to match the tax return to some sort of report that the servicemember has deployed to a combat zone. (Pro tip: this report to the IRS does not seem to come from DoD.) You’re welcome to call the IRS to confirm, but getting a human to help you respond to the letter is not always easy. I’m not sure an IRS human even sees the letter before it’s mailed to you.

Your best response to the letter request for your combat zone service dates is a written letter. If you want to be proactive, you can send the letter as soon as you return from deployment. (No operational security issues there!) You can also notify the IRS by e-mail about your combat zone service, but again, I’d wait until you’re home for OPSEC. 

Other suggestions include saving copies of your Leave and Earnings Statements, which cover the duration of the deployment.

The whole point of volunteering this information to the IRS is to give them your information to create an entry in your taxpayer account database telling the agency that you deployed to a combat zone. That way, when your tax return arrives at the IRS months later, the computer will already have a flag in the system to confirm your service. Ideally, it won’t spit out a form letter.

Here’s the IRS’s explanation:

Thank you for your e-mail dated Dec. 10, 201,8 and the information you sent in response to a 2761C letter.

The Department of Defense (DoD) is supposed to send us a Combat Zone Indicator (it converts to a Combat Zone Extension in our system) for every member of the military that is in a combat zone. The DoD is also supposed to send us a “spousal” indicator if the military member is married. When the military member exits the combat zone the DoD is supposed to send us the exit date.

This system worked well for a couple of decades. Over the past several years the DoD computer system and our computer system have had communication issues. Sometimes we get no indicator when a military member is in a combat zone, sometimes we get the entrance indicator and not the exit indicator, and sometimes we only get a spousal indicator.

The Internal Revenue Service is tasked with keeping accurate records for all taxpayers. To do so, we sometimes have to ask our taxpayers for help.

We apologize for any inconvenience we have caused you and sincerely thank you for helping us clean up our records.

You may be interested in Publication 3 Armed Forces’ Tax Guide. You can view it on our website or order it through our toll-free forms line at 1-800-829-3676 Mon – Fri 7:00 am – 7:00 pm your local time.

Your Call To Action

Once again, if you’ve opted into the BRS or are covered by it by default, ensure you contribute at least 5% of your base pay to the Thrift Savings Plan each month for the BRS match. Even if you’re still paying off debt, it makes sense to contribute to your TSP to at least get DoD’s free money in your TSP.

Once you know your deployment dates, download the spreadsheet and create your TSP contribution plan. It’d be great to have the income or assets to reach the annual additions limit, but do your best.

Whatever you decide to contribute, make sure you stay below an annual contribution of $24,500 in 2026 in the Roth TSP, or you’ll be locked out of additional contributions for that calendar year. When you’re in the BRS, that limit lockout will keep you from earning DoD BRS matching contributions for all 12 months of the year.

[The rest of the story:

The FRTIB’s policy is not clear in the tax code or in the TSP’s pamphlets and website.

I formed this opinion when an AFC and at least three other CFPs could not find a clear reference to the FRTIB’s policy in the tax code or the TSP’s public materials. (Despite one of them having seen the TSP’s training materials about the limits.) However, two servicemembers were already locked out of further TSP contributions in 2018. We knew they’d followed the rules on their Roth TSP limits. That meant there still could have been a glitch in the TSP computer system’s BRS software or that there’d been another mistake with implementing the legislation. Or… the TSP’s guidance on the annual additions limit was ambiguous.

The FRTIB says that it’s not a computer glitch. DoD’s BRS office (and Congress) can decide whether this is the way they want the TSP to work. There’s already been at least one proposal to change the tax code for Reserve/Guard servicemembers in the BRS who have highly-paid civilian jobs with 401(k) plans. My confusion over the annual additions limit would appear to be yet another unintended consequence of the BRS legislation on TSP contributions.

The good news is that the TSP training team has taken aboard our feedback and is updating their Blended Retirement System training materials. I’ll stay in touch with the TSP and with the DoD BRS office.

Here’s the FRTIB’s verbatim interpretation from one of their TSP Training & Liaison Specialists– one of the people handling the TSP’s Education and Outreach program.

“The answer is “no,” this individual already met their 402(g) elective deferral limit, and therefore would no longer be allowed to make contributions to their TSP (contributions that apply to the 415(c) limit and NOT the 402(g) limit are only CZTE pay contributions, so therefore if you are no longer receiving CZTE pay, any contributions apply to the 402(g) limit, which again, was already met).”

Let me break down that 65-word sentence into smaller clauses.

When you return home from the combat zone, you can still contribute to your TSP accounts– but only up to the elective deferral limit ($18,500 in 2018, $19K in 2019) in each account. The TSP’s website and pamphlets are clear on only being able to contribute combat zone tax-exempt pay above the elective deferral limit in the traditional TSP when you’re in the combat zone. However, they’re not so clear on how you can contribute taxable pay to your traditional TSP after you return home.

One of my smarter friends (a military retiree and a CFP) suggested thinking of it this way: when you’re home, count down from the limits instead of counting up. “How much have I reduced my elective deferral limit in each of my TSP accounts? How much room do I have left to contribute to each one?”

Alert readers will note that the servicemember in the contribution spreadsheet example received a $30K retention bonus while in the combat zone. If they signed that contract in the combat zone, then every one of the subsequent annual installments of that bonus is also tax-free… even if they’re not in the combat zone. Could they contribute the next few years’ installments of that CZTE pay to their traditional TSP up to the annual additions limit?

My answer: I don’t know. I’m going to let the FRTIB and the BRS office clarify those interpretations of the tax code. The good news is that DFAS already knows the bonus contract is tax-free and will reflect it on your W-2.]

Military Guide to Financial Independence

This book provides servicemembers, veterans, and their families with a critical roadmap for becoming financially independent. Topics include:
  • Military pension
  • TSP
  • Tricare Health System
  • & More

The post How to Maximize TSP Contributions in a Combat Zone appeared first on The Military Wallet.

]]>
https://themilitarywallet.com/maximizing-your-thrift-savings-plan-contributions-in-a-combat-zone/feed/ 63
How to File a VA Disability Claim https://themilitarywallet.com/file-va-disability-claim/ https://themilitarywallet.com/file-va-disability-claim/#respond Tue, 01 Feb 2022 21:37:14 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=16807 Former military members who incurred injuries that prevent them from being able to perform at their best have a contractual right to be compensated for those injuries.
They may have to settle for a job that pays less or one in a field they don’t enjoy. Veterans disability compensation fills financial gaps so that veterans can maintain a comfortable lifestyle and take care of their families, even if a disability prevents them from doing a job that would pay more.

The post How to File a VA Disability Claim appeared first on The Military Wallet.

]]>
Former military members who incurred injuries that prevent them from performing at their best have a contractual right to compensation for those injuries.

Veterans who are injured may have to settle for a job that pays less or a job in a field they don’t enjoy. Veteran disability compensation fills financial gaps so veterans can take care of themselves and their families while living with a service-connected illness or injury.

There are many benefits to VA compensation, other than just the cash compensation.

First, the money is tax-free, so veterans who qualify for retirement can accept VA compensation instead and save on taxes.

In some cases, veterans can get both retired pay and VA compensation.

A disability status can also save you money on tolls, property taxes or other state programs and fees.

Veterans who qualify for VA loans can save money on the VA funding fee if they have a disability rating.

Disability compensation may also provide school benefits to cover education for themselves or their families.

All those pennies add up.

But first, the VA needs to connect your condition to your military service and provide a rating.

Veterans: Are you under 90% rated?

Winning approval for military service-connected injuries and illnesses can be a challenging process. Be confident that you’re getting the compensation that you medically, legally, and ethically qualify for.

Answer a few quick questions to get the most accurate veteran disability rating that your conditions warrant here.

Eligibility Requirements for VA Disability Compensation

If you became sick, injured or began to experience mental health difficulties because of active duty, active duty for training or inactive duty training, you may be eligible for VA disability compensation.

Pre-existing conditions that became worse during your service may also qualify for compensation.

Some conditions, such as tinnitus and hearing loss, may have appeared years after you left the military but still qualify for VA benefits.

In any of the above cases, you must be able to link your condition to your service.

How to Prepare Before Filing a VA Disability Claim

You’ll need to gather all your medical evidence and related service records before you file a VA disability claim.

Some of the following steps may not apply to you, depending on your service status.

1. Document and Save Everything

If you are still in the military, report everything to your doctor.

If you’re concerned that the military medical community may ground you (or even disqualify you), then at least take care of your health with a civilian doctor (and get a copy of those records).

Document injuries, ailments, exposure to hazardous substances or environments, any treatments you receive and their impact on your life or ability to do your job. Keep track of temporary duty travel and deployment dates and locations too. You will need lots of supporting evidence for your claim.

2. Ask for Your Records and Review Them

You need to request your medical records and review them.

Start by tracking down any records from civilian medical providers that are related to injuries or illnesses you intend to claim. The VA should be able to access your military records.

If you’ve been seen at a VA medical facility, the VA benefits division will have access to those records. Just tell the Veterans Benefits Administration which VA medical facility has the records.

Look at your medications list and what injuries have been documented.

Pay special attention to what diagnoses you have on paper. If your medical record is inaccurate or just plain wrong, you’ll need to fix it.

For instance, if a physician told you that you slipped a disk, but your diagnosis just says “back pain,” you may need to go back and get your diagnosis put on paper.

You can also request an exam by a different doctor who could help reconstruct the events leading to your current condition on paper.

3. Reach Out to Your Family and Friends

If something occurred that is not officially documented, a supporting statement from someone who knew about your condition can go a long way.

You can ask for summaries or “buddy statements” from friends or coworkers who were with you when you sought medical advice, or observed a condition’s impact on your life.

The VA reviews buddy statements as evidence when records are limited or when you’re several years post service.

For example:

  • Your roommates in the service constantly complained about how you’d started snoring, and now you’ve been diagnosed with sleep apnea.
  • A fellow soldier witnessed you fall on your knee in physical training.
  • You wrote a letter or email to your mom about having no ear protection during an exercise. A few years later you found out that you can’t hear as well.

4. Review Your Military Records

Look at what’s in your service record. This information can also assist in your claim. Look for documentation for reported injuries, medals or awards that show your working conditions (such as Combat Infantry Badge, Purple Heart, parachutist badge, etc.), your MOS, rating or specialty and any additional duties or jobs you performed.

The bottom line is that you need evidence on paper. Without that, you’re wasting your time with the VA.

5. Research VA Disability Criteria

Make sure you read and understand the VA’s disability benefits questionnaires. These can help you determine if the VA considers your condition to be disabling.

Pay attention to presumptive conditions associated with your period of service.

For example, the VA presumes that Vietnam veterans may have had Agent Orange exposure. Gulf War veterans may have been exposed to burning oil wells. Navy engineers may have had asbestos exposure from steam-pipe lagging. Submariners might have been exposed to radiation.

If you’re experiencing symptoms or conditions connected to these exposures, you should report it to the VA.

Ways to Apply for VA Disability Benefits

You will need to complete VA Form 21-526EZ, “Application for Disability Compensation and Related Compensation Benefit” and submit it with all applicable evidence and records.

You can do it in one of the following ways.

  • Online: The easiest way to submit a claim is to sign into your VA.gov account and apply online.
  • By mail: You can also submit it by mail. Print off the form and all supporting documents and send to:

Department of Veterans Affairs

Claims Intake Center

PO Box 4444

Janesville, WI 53547-4444

  • In-person: Visit a VA regional office near you and submit your documents in person.

Steps to File a VA Disability Claim

1. Submit an Intent to File (if Applicable)

If you are applying for a disability claim by mail or in person, notifying the VA of your intent is the first step.

You can visit a VA regional office near you and do it in person or call them at 800-827-1000.

You can also complete VA Form 21-0966, Intent to File a Claim for Compensation and/or Pension or Survivors Pension and/or DIC, and mail it to the address above.

If you are applying for a VA disability claim online, clicking on the button to start the process serves as submitting your intent to file.

However you contact the VA about your intent to file, make sure you note the date.

You have one year from that date to submit your claim. If you receive disability compensation for your claim, the VA may backdate your benefits to the date you submitted your intent to file.

2. Submit Medical Evidence and Service Records

You’ll include your DD-214 to prove your dates of service and the character of your discharge.

Some VA benefits, including compensation amounts, are linked to your family status. so you should include your marriage certificate (even if you’re married to another military veteran) and birth certificates for any minor children who you’re still financially supporting.

You’ll also include copies of all the medical evidence that you’ve been tracking down, such as doctor’s reports, X-rays and medical test results).

You can give the VA permission to gather this evidence for you. However, you retain much more control over the process if you do it yourself. You’ll also get your results faster because you’ve done the VA’s ground work for them.

3. Verify if Additional Documentation is Needed

You may need to submit additional forms or statements.

For example, if you are a National Guard or Reserve member, you’ll need to submit all your service, medical and personnel records from your unit.

Certain disability claims have additional requirements.

These include:

  • Post-traumatic stress syndrome
  • Auto allowances or an auto adaptive-equipment grants
  • Aid and Attendance for nursing home care

You can find the full list on the VA website.

4. Complete and Submit Your Application

Complete all sections of your VA Form 21-526EZ, Application for Disability Compensation and related Compensation Benefits. Make sure that you have retained copies of this form and any supporting documents you include.

Finally, submit your claim. (After all the record-gathering and research, filing the claim is admittedly anticlimactic).

5. Track Your VA Disability Claim Status

Now that your claim has been filed, you can track it with your eBenefits account. The VA will update your dashboard with the status of your claim and any messages they need to send to you. This may include requests for additional information.

You may also be contacted by phone or mail if you are required to have a VA claim exam, also known as a compensation and pension (C&P) exam.

While you’re on your eBenefits account, add your bank account information so that the VA can distribute your compensation (if any) by direct deposit.

How to File an Additional VA Disability Claim

Your claims process isn’t necessarily over once the VA confirms your disability is service-connected.

You may want to file one of these additional VA disability claims under certain circumstances:

  • Increased claim to increase your disability rating or financial support
  • New claim for additional benefits, such as a shift to individual unemployability status
  • Secondary service-connected disability claim if you develop a new condition that is linked to an existing service-connected disability, such as heart disease caused by high blood pressure
  • Special claim for special needs, such as a specially equipped vehicle

You’d make these claims in the same manner as your original claim.

Complete an application for disability compensation and related compensation benefits (VA Form 21-526EZ) and submit it online, in person or by mail, along with the required medical evidence.

How Long Do I Have to File a VA Disability Claim?

There is no deadline to file a VA disability claim, but the process can become more difficult as time passes and may take longer.

Your service status or separation date can also impact your effective date, which is the date you’ll begin receiving compensation (or back payment).

Filing a VA Claim Before Leaving the Military

You can file up to 180 days before discharge. Even if it’s a disability that is not bothering you now, you can at least get a 0% service-connected disability rating if you have a diagnosis.

Doing this now makes it easier to file for an increase later if your condition worsens (instead of filing a whole new claim to convince the VA that the injury happened in service).

Filing a VA Claim When You Leave the Service

When you’re leaving the service, start your VA disability claim in conjunction with your separation physical.

It’s much easier to do it in parallel with your physical, and it’s the best time to document any “service-connected” disability. Even if you feel disgustingly healthy, file the claim now for anything you have a diagnosis for so that it’s on the record if a surprise pops up later.

Filing a VA Claim After Leaving the Service

If you’ve already separated yet haven’t filed a VA disability claim yet, then start one now so that your loved ones won’t ever have to do it for you.

Even if the VA decides that you’re 0% disabled, you’ve done the hard work so that the VA can upgrade your rating later if you begin to experience a debilitating condition.

Can I File a VA Claim Myself?

You can file a claim on your own, but the process is time-consuming and complicated.

There are individuals who have training and experience filing disability claims who can assist you with the process and help you avoid common mistakes that could delay your claim or result in a less beneficial outcome for your claim.

Who Can Help Me File a Claim for VA Disability?

If you need help filing a disability claim, contact a VA regional office and ask to speak to a counselor.

To find the nearest regional office, call 800-827-1000.

Veteran Service Organizations (VSOs) can help and are free. Many are also VA-accredited.

The VA website can help you find a VSO representative to assist you with your claim.

Here is their exhaustive list of Veteran Service Organizations. There are also state and county VSO reps you can see on this site or this one. Take the time to find one who is the right fit for you.

If you don’t want to use a free VSO and you have the money to spend, you can choose to hire a VA disability lawyer to assist you with your claim. This may be a good option if your case is very complex, if your initial claim didn’t go well or if you’re concerned about the appeal. Make sure that your lawyer has specialized knowledge and experience in the area of VA disability claims.

How Long Does It Take the VA to Process My Claim?

The VA will let you know once they receive your claim. Then, they’ll gather and review evidence from you and your healthcare providers and make a decision. Once they’ve decided, they’ll mail you a claim notification packet.

According to the VA, this process will take approximately 156 days for a new claim.

If you submit a supplemental claim, the VA should notify you of their decision within 125 days.

What to Do if Your VA Disability Claim is Denied

You have limited time to appeal a denied claim and maintain your initial effective date. If the VA denies your claim, file the appropriate appeal within the time allotted – one year in most cases.

There are several types of appeal options. Here are the main three:

  • File a supplemental claim. If you have new, relevant evidence, you can file a supplemental claim at any time. It’s preferable to file within a year of the original decision.
  • Higher-level review. You have one year from the date of the decision letter to request that a senior reviewer go over your request. You cannot submit new evidence, but you can speak with the reviewer by phone to highlight any errors.
  • Board appeal. A Veterans Law Judge at the Board of Veterans’ Appeals in Washington, D.C. will review your disability claim. With this option, you have three additional choices to make about how your appeal will be handled: Direct review, submit more evidence or request a hearing.

Top VA Disability Claims

According to the Veterans Benefits Administration’s Benefits Report for 2020, the top 10 VA disability claims were:

  1. Tinnitus
  2. Hearing loss
  3. Limitation of flexion, knee
  4. Post-traumatic stress disorder
  5. Lumbosacral or cervical strain
  6. Scars, general
  7. Paralysis of the sciatic nerve
  8. Limitation of motion of the ankle
  9. Migraine
  10. Limitation of motion of the arm

Other common disability claims include sleep apnea, hypertensive vascular disease, degenerative arthritis of the spine and diabetes mellitus.

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Filing a VA Disability Claim

  • Thinking you don’t deserve it. VA disability compensation is not charity. It’s a benefit. If you have a qualifying service-related disability, you have earned disability compensation. Don’t be embarrassed to accept something that could make your life easier. You never know what the future holds.
  • Not understanding the value of VA benefits. It’s not just about the compensation. You are potentially eligible for a host of other veterans’ benefits, including vocational rehabilitation, medical care, education and reduced fees on VA loans.
  • Being tough. When it comes to filing a VA disability claim, if it’s not in your records, it didn’t happen (with some exceptions). Go see a doctor (non-VA if necessary). Don’t minimize your symptoms, and don’t avoid treatment.
  • Not including secondary medical conditions. These are more common than you might think. Make sure you are communicating with your doctor about all of your symptoms. They may be able to educate you about what additional conditions may result from existing primary medical conditions. You may be eligible for additional compensation for secondary conditions.
  • Not keeping copies of all your records. If this applies to you, you will need to track down all your medical and military records to back your claim. Once your claim is complete, request a copy of your claims file (the C-file) from the VA.
  • Waiting until the last minute to request your records. You may be waiting on these records for several months.
  • Missing deadlines: The VA is unforgiving if you are even one day late on your claim. If you don’t submit your claim within a year of notifying them of your intent to file, you will need to start over. If you miss the deadline for an appeal, you may not be able to file one.

Military Guide to Financial Independence

This book provides servicemembers, veterans, and their families with a critical roadmap for becoming financially independent. Topics include:
  • Military pension
  • TSP
  • Tricare Health System
  • & More

The post How to File a VA Disability Claim appeared first on The Military Wallet.

]]>
https://themilitarywallet.com/file-va-disability-claim/feed/ 0
What is Military Sanctuary? https://themilitarywallet.com/military-retirement-sanctuary/ https://themilitarywallet.com/military-retirement-sanctuary/#comments Wed, 15 Sep 2021 17:25:00 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=17863 The military sanctuary program safeguards retirement eligibility, letting members serve until they earn their retirement. We simplify this complex topic for better understanding.

The post What is Military Sanctuary? appeared first on The Military Wallet.

]]>
The military Sanctuary Program protects military members’ retirement eligibility and allows them to continue their service until they have earned their retirement.

For most servicemembers, this means that once you reach 18 years of active duty service, you will be allowed to remain on active duty long enough to get 20 years of active duty service and earn full military retirement benefits.

Sanctuary is an often misunderstood topic, especially for those serving in the Guard and Reserves. This article will cover the topic of Sanctuary and address many of the myths and misconceptions surrounding it.

Key Takeaways: 

  • The Sanctuary Program allows reservists to remain on active duty until they reach 20 years of service, ensuring eligibility for full military retirement benefits.
  • Sanctuary status applies only when reservists are on active duty (not training) and cross the 18-year mark on orders longer than 29 days.
  • Approval for Sanctuary is based on urgent military needs, not as a reward for reserve duty.
  • Myths about qualifying for Sanctuary include accruing 18 Good Years or reaching 6,574 points; actual qualification requires being on active-duty orders at the 18-year mark and may involve signing waivers.
  • Promotions during Sanctuary can reset retirement dates and restart careers, depending on service needs and approvals.

Qualifying for Military Sanctuary Retirement

The Sanctuary Program was established in federal law Title 10 U.S. Code section 12686. 

In simple terms, the law states if you’re a Reservist on active duty (not for training) who goes over 18 years of active duty points (while on active duty), then you get to stay on active duty until you’re eligible for an active-duty retirement at 20 years.

To reemphasize that point, Sanctuary only happens when you’re on active duty.

However, the Sanctuary program is also derived from the broader protection of federal law (Title 10 U.S. Code section 1176) regarding involuntary discharge. This law states that every member of the military (on active duty) within two years of retirement is entitled to stay on active duty until they’re eligible for their active-duty pension.

This broader law is the source of most of the misunderstandings surrounding the Sanctuary program.  Many reservists think that they’ll automatically qualify for Sanctuary if they have 18 years of points, or more than 6,574 points, or by being on any kind of Reserve order. Some believe that accumulating 7,200 or 7,300 points makes one eligible for an immediate active-duty retirement. Or maybe they know someone who heard of someone who manipulated the Reserve bureaucracy into issuing orders and then ambushed the chain of command by claiming Sanctuary for an immediate active-duty retirement. 

There are many myths and misunderstandings about Sanctuary. I’ll do my best to address them and shed as much light as possible. 

Below, I’ve linked each service’s applicable instructions and information sheets.

Branch Policies and Instruction Sheets

Air Force Sanctuary Instruction

Army Sanctuary Instruction

Coast Guard Sanctuay Instruction

Marine Corps Sanctuary Instruction

Navy Sanctuary Instruction

Sanctuary is Only Approved When There is a Great Need

The most misunderstood aspect of Sanctuary is that it only happens when your service has an urgent need for your skills. Sanctuary is not a reward for your years of Reserve duty or mobilizations. 

There are servicemembers I know who have claimed Sanctuary or who have written to me to share what they’ve learned from it. They were able to claim Sanctuary because they had irreplaceable skills the military needed right then like a trauma surgeon or a combat-experienced officer to fill a critical billet on a joint warfare commander’s staff.

Another important detail of Sanctuary is that it costs your service a lot of money. When you apply for a Reserve retirement, the Department of Defense (DoD) funds your pension. However, the DoD will not pay the bill for a Sanctuary-related pension. When a service decides that they need to mobilize you into Sanctuary, they have to be willing to fund it with their own money.

When a Reserve or Guard member claims Sanctuary and “upgrades” from a Reserve pension to an active-duty pension, the DoD makes the service pay the active-duty pension out of their personnel funds until the retiree reaches age 60. When your service gives you a Sanctuary “sweet deal,” it’s because they’re fixing a crisis.

What Happens When You’re Close to Sanctuary

To avoid overuse of this program and the expense of Sanctuary, Reserve and Guard personnel staff spend a lot of time and money tracking your point count. If you go over 16 years of (active duty) points, you’re placed in a special database to ensure that your service doesn’t inadvertently enable you to reach Sanctuary.

Once you’ve reached 16 years, any new active duty orders over 29 days require approval at higher levels of the chain of command. Additionally, any orders that would put you into Sanctuary status have to be approved by your service’s personnel general or admiral.

Another common misconception is that Sanctuary eligibility can happen on any type of order. The reality is that a servicemember has to be mobilized and on active duty when they cross the 18-year line into Sanctuary.

This means you are not eligible for Sanctuary if you’re on Active Training (AT), Active Duty Training (ADT), or any other sort of training orders. This misunderstanding was the subject of at least one Sanctuary lawsuit. 

The servicemember also has to agree to stay on active duty until they’re eligible for a regular active-duty retirement, and they are issued a new set of orders to take them to that date. They can’t be extended past 20 years for any other reason – unless they leave their Reserve/Guard status and apply for permanent active-duty status.

A final misconception is that the military has to approve Sanctuary. Even if mobilization orders are approved, you could still be required to sign a waiver of your Sanctuary rights. 

Waiving your right to Sanctuary is controversial, but it’s allowed by federal law for mobilizations less than 180 days, and it has been upheld in court. You may wonder why someone would waive their right to Sanctuary, but they might still want the mobilization orders for a compelling mission or to boost their career or pay.

During your Reserve/Guard career, you can rack up more than 20 Good Years or go over 6574 points (not an easy task, but not impossible). You could do all the drill weekends and training orders you want, even if your “training” is flying an Air National Guard tanker mission for active-duty aircraft. But you won’t make Sanctuary or be eligible for an active-duty retirement unless you’re mobilized on active-duty orders of more than 29 days. Even when you meet all of the conditions, your service may ask you to waive your right to Sanctuary.

Reader Questions

Given that Sanctuary can be a complex topic, I’d like to address some reader questions and clarify their specific scenarios. 

Reader Question #1: I’m close to Sanctuary. How can I qualify?

A reader writes:

“I’m currently deployed to overseas. I am very close to Sanctuary and may reach it during the end of my leave after my deployment is over. If I don’t reach Sanctuary by the end of this deployment, I will return to the Reserves with no less than 17 years and 11 months of ‘active federal’ time. If I remain in the Reserves and get orders to perform duty over 30 days, that will put me well over 18 years.

I’m wondering if I have to be mobilized to apply for Sanctuary or if I can be on ‘active duty’ orders to reach my 18 years and achieve Sanctuary. Because of my MOS, I am constantly on orders longer than 30 days at a given time.”

If you cross over 18 years of service on a set of active-duty orders, whether you’re on duty or leave, then you’ve reached Sanctuary status. The only thing that matters is being on those orders as you cross over 18 years. If you’ve demobilized and returned to Reserve status before 18 years, then you’ll only reach Sanctuary if you go back on active-duty orders and cross over 18 years while on those orders.

The key to “active-duty orders” is a set of orders longer than 29 days, which means that you’re receiving active-duty benefits and no longer considered “in training.” AT or ADT orders do not count because they’re 29 days or less. If you’re on active duty orders for longer than 29 days when you cross 18 years, whether those orders are Active Duty for Special Work Support (ADSW) or a full-blown mobilization, then you’re in Sanctuary.

Your service will track your active-duty time and will know when a set of orders would put you in Sanctuary because your service has to pay the difference in pension before DoD takes over that funding.

Remaining in Reserve status can be risky. You could miss out on hundreds of thousands of dollars from an active duty pension should policies change, budgets decrease, or you are otherwise unable to be placed on active duty orders to reach Sanctuary.

If I were in your situation (with a heightened awareness of abrupt policy changes), I’d first determine exactly when I’d go over 18 years of active duty. I’d try to extend the current mobilization to cross over 18 on that set of orders before demobilizing. If that didn’t work, I’d get back on any active-duty orders as soon as I demobilized so that I was getting to 18 as quickly as possible.

Once you’re in Sanctuary, you can apply for integration into your service’s active-duty forces and then request to stay on active duty until you’re promoted and reach at least two years’ time in grade.

Reader Question #2: Can I be promoted while in Sanctuary?

Here’s a reader question from a servicemember who is currently in Sanctuary:

“You seem to have a pretty good handle on the Reserve military retirement system, and I would like to ask your opinion on my situation. I’m in the Reserves. I’ve been mobilized, and I am currently in Sanctuary (18 years, nine months of active-duty service) with a mandatory active-duty retirement date of May 2014. I’ve just been selected for promotion. Since I will not have the opportunity for time in grade to retire at that rank before May 2014, is there a waiver process or any system that will allow me to continue past the mandatory date? Or, will my retirement be based on the High Three average in May 2014, and that is it?

One last question: Do you know if the inactive points count towards a Sanctuary retirement, or is it the straight 20 years of active time (assuming retirement at that point)?  Thanks!”

Congratulations on your promotion! You’ve won the game in the third quarter, and now the question is how far you get to run up the score.

Reserve Retirement and Promotions

Let me start by explaining the Reserves background to your question and how a different set of rules applies to your active-duty retirement.

There are waivers of time in grade for Reserve retirements. DoD lets the individual Reserve services decide how to handle their waivers (down to two years’ time in grade (TIG)). The services generously approve the waivers during drawdowns, although I don’t know how far below two years they would be willing to go. The approvals I’ve seen were for those who will reach a minimum of two years TIG, but the only way to determine your service’s limit is to request the waiver.

In your case, your promotion resets the clock on your retirement date and restarts your active-duty career. When you’re promoted during active duty in Sanctuary, your retirement orders are canceled, and you stay on active duty for a whole new ballgame. You get to serve whatever minimum TIG your service will allow, or you could continue your career with follow-on orders. You’ve rebooted your career, and you’re competitive for more promotions, should you choose to consider that lifestyle.

I’m going to speculate that the reason your chain of command hasn’t discussed the rules is that your promotion is not yet final. When you’re promoted (not just selected), the active-duty personnel staff will note your Sanctuary retirement date and modify your promotion orders to cancel the retirement. You may also be asked to extend your current orders for a full two years TIG.

If you want to do as little time in your new rank as possible, then I’d apply for approval of either:

  • A new retirement date to give you two years’ time in grade at your new rank
  • A time in grade waiver to retire in May ’14 with however many months you have at that grade.

Hopefully, you could discuss this ahead of time with your chain of command and HQ staff. If you apply for the waiver as an either/or option, then the approval staff should consider it in those terms.

Do inactive points count toward Sanctuary?

Your Reserve Good Years clock was ticking before you were mobilized, and now it’s continuing to track the longevity of your rank for your pay scale. Right now, you have 18 years and a few months of active service, but your pay scale longevity is probably at the >20 years, >22, or even higher column. That’s based on your date of initial entry into military service (DIEMS).

To manually determine your pension amount, you’ll also need your years of service. The DoD has already conveniently determined this for you: you’ll reach 20 years on 1 May 2014. If you remain on active duty longer (at your higher rank), then your years of service will count up from there.

The good news is your inactive Reserve points count toward your retirement pension after you reach 20 years of active duty service. These points are calculated by adding them together and dividing them by 360. The value of those points is converted to months and added to your active duty time when you retire, boosting your retirement pay accordingly. 

To calculate your monthly High 3 pension amount, you’ll take that average 36 months’ base pay for those ranks at their longevity columns, multiply it by your years of service (calculated to three decimals), multiply that by 2.5%, and round it down to the nearest dollar.

Reader Question #3: What are the time in grade requirements in Sanctuary?

A reader writes:

“My spouse was selected for promotion before reaching Sanctuary. He was promoted after being issued Sanctuary orders but before his deployment. We were completely unaware of the ‘promotion during active duty in Sanctuary’ rule that would cancel his retirement orders and allow him to stay on active duty for his promotion time in grade. The military has NOT canceled his retirement orders and told him to submit a time-in-grade waiver request. He was then informed his Sanctuary orders could not be extended. However, he didn’t tell them he was recently promoted – would that make a difference? No one at the G1 Pentagon has notified him, nor were his promotion orders modified to cancel his retirement.

His Date of Initial Entry on Military Service is May 1987. He was issued Sanctuary orders in September 2012, he was promoted to O-6 on 1 December 2012, and the Sanctuary orders ended in May 2014. Can you please clarify or point me to the regulation regarding the ‘promotion during active duty in Sanctuary’ rule? Thank you for your help.

P.S. The information on calculating his pay was very helpful and good news because we thought the annuity calculation would be based on 20 years of service and not consider his longevity which will be close to 26 years. So that was very good news if I am reading that correctly!!”

Note: this answer was drafted in 2013 and references things that were happening in the Military around then.

After some questions, the reader and I came up with the following chronology:

  • May 1987: DIEMS.
  • June 1999: Separated from active duty for drilling Reserve. Completed Good Years of Reserve points each year.
  • 2006: Placed on active-duty contingency orders through 2012.
    • This was nearly continuous active service, including a deployment.
  • November 2011: Selected for promotion.
  • 1 June 2012: Reached 18 years of active duty orders (Sanctuary).
  • September 2012: Received Sanctuary orders.
  • 1 December 2012: Promoted to O-6.
  • March 2013: Deployed for one year.
  • 1 June 2014: Sanctuary orders end at 20 years of service.

This question addresses a slightly different situation in which a servicemember was selected for promotion before they reached Sanctuary and then promoted after the Sanctuary orders were released.

Remember, Sanctuary is expensive. A servicemember is not usually allowed to continue on active duty past the 20-year retirement eligibility unless they integrate with the active-duty service.

I’ve heard of several servicemembers reaching Sanctuary, but I’ve only heard of one who continued past 20 years of service. In that situation, he was selected for promotion while he was on his Sanctuary orders. When the selection list was approved (and he was on the promotion schedule), he applied for integration with his active duty service. He stayed on active duty long enough to serve the minimum time in grade of his higher rank. Then, he retired on an active-duty pension.

This reader’s spouse has a slightly different situation. He’d already been selected for promotion before he reached Sanctuary. He was promoted shortly after his Sanctuary orders were issued.

DoD Instruction 1235.12 allows servicemembers to continue on active duty if their service secretary approves. A Department of the Army memorandum says:

“Sanctuary orders are not authorized to be amended to reflect a period beyond the end of the month in which the Soldier attains 20 years of active service. In cases of approved Active Duty for Operational Support service beyond 20 years of active service, the Soldier will be placed on a new set of orders, and the Sanctuary provisions of 10 USC 12686 will no longer apply.”

How does that happen? A few paragraphs later, the memo says:

“Officers in Sanctuary status may apply for Regular Army integration through the Call to Active Duty Program, and enlisted Soldiers in Sanctuary status may apply for Regular Army enlistment through the Reserve Component to Active Component Program. Officers in Sanctuary status should be advised that the CAD Program is a competitive accession program based upon the needs of the Army; there is no guarantee of approval. […] If approved and accessed into the Regular Army, the Soldier is subject to world-wide assignment based on the needs of the Army.”

Those are the rules, but Sanctuary is a unique program, and most personnel staff aren’t familiar with it. Each service’s headquarters personnel staff has a Sanctuary program manager, usually a senior civil servant who’s had years to become familiar with the details. In this case, the servicemember needs to speak with the program manager to ensure they understand how the servicemember got to Sanctuary and when they were selected for promotion. 

They need to do that even though they’re on deployment, or they will waste a lot of time hearing different interpretations from lower levels of the chain of command. The program manager will be required to investigate this integration request anyway, so they might as well discuss the situation with the servicemember before the official application reaches their desk.

This servicemember will reach 20 years of service after only 18 months in the O-6 pay grade. Title 10 U.S. Code Section 1370 requires higher-ranking officers to serve three years in that grade to retire at that grade, but each service has the waiver authority to reduce that time to two years. Anything less than two years time in grade requires approval by SECDEF and Congress, which essentially means “don’t even ask about it.” (SECDEF does not want to explain to interested Congressional committees why some officers don’t have to serve their minimum two years’ TIG.)

The only way for this Sanctuary servicemember to reach TIG in their higher rank is to apply for integration into the Regular Army. After that approval, they could hope for a new set of orders to remain in their current assignment for at least another six months (while applying for a TIG waiver down to two years when they retire), or they could receive a new set of orders to another duty station.

Will this servicemember be allowed to integrate into the Regular Army and gain at least six more months of active duty to retire at their higher grade? That’s hard to predict. A few years ago, they might have been eagerly integrated and issued new orders, especially for deployment.

Now that the drawdown has started, the Army could be reluctant to integrate anyone else into the Regular Army (let alone give them more time on active duty) if they initially reached retirement orders on Sanctuary. The timing is very awkward for the service because it would require staying on active duty past the end of a fiscal year. An additional six months of active duty would need that officer to count against end-of-year personnel strength. It will be tough enough to comply with the drawdown requirements, and personnel staff will be reluctant to issue new orders to anyone without a mission-critical reason. A general officer could intervene with Army G-1 to plead this case, but general officers in a drawdown are only issued a few silver bullets.

The “worst-case scenario” is the servicemember reaches 20 years of active-duty service in May 2014 and will be required to retire on 1 June 2014 as an O-5 instead of an O-6. Their DD-214 and their retiree ID would reflect an O-5 rank.

Because the officer is retiring from active duty on the High 3 system, his retired rank doesn’t matter for the pension calculation. The only things that count are years of service and the average of the highest 36 months of pay.

Their pension has to be calculated manually because of their Reserve pay scales and active-duty years of service. Since his DIEMS is May 1987 and he’s had a Good Year every year in the Reserves, he went over 24 years of service in June 2011 (the start of this 36-month period) and over 26 years of service in June 2013. The 18 months of O-5 pay is at the O-5>24 columns of the pay tables. The 18 months of O-6 pay is at the O-6>24 and O-6>26 columns.

Reader Question #4: Am I eligible?

“I currently have 30 years of service (13 active and 17 reserves) with 6,405 points. I’m considering applying for Sanctuary next year. I’d like to know which scenario would benefit me more financially if I retire as active duty with 20 years (if I get Sanctuary status) or as a gray area reservist.”

Reader #4 could request mobilization, but he’s already being tracked for Sanctuary status (and he was probably added to that database when he crossed 5,840 active-duty points). Even if he has a unique skill in high demand, he’ll only be mobilized if there’s a critical mission– and then he’ll be asked to sign a waiver for 179-day orders. He’ll go over 18 years of points, but no Sanctuary. He’ll eventually apply for a Reserve retirement.

Reader Question #5: Does earning 7,200 points make me eligible for active duty retirement?

“I understand that Reservists who’ve earned at least 7,200 retirement points by their last day of Reserve duty become eligible for an immediate active duty retirement. If so, will they immediately receive retirement pay for BOTH the accumulated active duty points AND the inactive duty points, or must they wait through the “grey area” for the inactive duty points?

Does accumulating 7,300 total points of inactive duty points and active duty time and over 20 satisfactory years warrant an active duty retirement right away, or does the member still collect at age 60?”

The biggest difference between active duty and Reserve Component retirement is that active duty members can collect their retirement after completing 20 qualifying years of service, whereas Guard/Reserve members typically have to wait until age 60 to collect. 

The reason 7,200 comes up is that points are used to convert Guard/Reserve retirement to years when calculating their eligibility. This does not mean that earning 7,200 or 7,300 points qualifies you for an active duty retirement. As stated by the ARPC, active duty retirement is qualified for based on your service, not points. 

Reader Contribution: Are you required to sign a Sanctuary waiver?

“I was reading your blog about Reserve retirements. I see that someone asked a question about a Reservist accumulating 20 active years and figuring out their retirement pay. I fall into that category too. I would love to correspond with you to help me understand what retirement pay I will be entitled to after my 20 active years and 24 years of good service total.

Between my seven years of regular active duty and my slew of Reserve voluntary active duty orders at other commands, I will have 20 actual active years of service in a few months.

Ever since I was close to 16 years of active service, I have been required to sign a Sanctuary waiver to be allowed to come on orders. That was so I would not claim Sanctuary after 18 years of active service.

However, I have been blessed enough to achieve the 20 active years!

At the beginning of next year, I will have 7,629 points.”

This reader loves what she does, and she gets a lot of short-term active-duty orders. Her Sanctuary status was tracked as soon as she crossed 16 years of points, and she’s all too familiar with the Sanctuary waivers.

Stay Up-to-Date On Military Retirement Topics and News

Stay informed on the latest military retirement and financial topics by subscribing to our newsletter. Don’t miss out on important updates and expert insights sent straight to your inbox.

The post What is Military Sanctuary? appeared first on The Military Wallet.

]]>
https://themilitarywallet.com/military-retirement-sanctuary/feed/ 123
Transitioning from Active Duty to Reserves Or National Guard https://themilitarywallet.com/leave-active-duty-for-reserves/ https://themilitarywallet.com/leave-active-duty-for-reserves/#comments Mon, 28 Jun 2021 19:37:00 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=17454 Putting 20 years of military active duty service is the quickest way to earn retirement benefits, but what if it becomes too much? Going from active duty to the Reserve or National Guard is an option for those who may no longer find active duty challenging and fulfilling but still want a military career and retirement benefits.

The post Transitioning from Active Duty to Reserves Or National Guard appeared first on The Military Wallet.

]]>
The magic number for military members is 20. For active duty members it’s the number of years  you must serve to get access to your military retirement benefits. Reserve and Guard members also need 20 eligible years for military retirement, the only caveat being that they can’t access their pension until age 60. However, if you need a change of pace, this might be a small price to pay. 

So often, career servicemembers get locked into a single line of thinking that drives them to put their head down and continue their military career until reaching that magic number of 20 years of active duty service, regardless of the cost.

As a retired Navy veteran and author of The Military Guide to Financial Independence and Retirement, I’m here to tell you that if you are struggling with the commitment of serving 20 years on active duty, you have options.

Can You Really Retire After 20 Years in the Military?

Some active duty members want to stay in the military after serving 20 years and qualifying for retirement. 

You can stay in the military or join the Reserves after qualifying for retirement, but if you stay in the service you won’t be able to draw on your pension. 

If you decide to go to the reserves after qualifying for retirement, you essentially “cash in” your retirement for reserve points. This allows you to gain reserve points toward your retirement and potentially earn a higher pension when you do retire.

Now, there is a loophole if you’re a warrant officer. Warrant officers can withdraw retirement while serving in the Reserves. You’re also able to receive promotions. When you retire from the Reserves, the military will re-calculate your retirement, adding the time you served in the Reserves.

However, you don’t have to wait until you’ve served 20 active duty years to move to the Reserves. In fact, you can switch at any point from active duty to Reserves and still continue building toward your retirement and financial independence.

Active Duty or Reserves: What’s Best For You?

This post gets a bit personal. Let me permit you to think about these questions in your career.

A reader writes:

“I’m active duty and coming up on year #9 this May. I have owned your book for a few years and dig into the blog content on occasion. Love it!

My question has to do specifically with one of the closing paragraphs in your last post on the BRS:

‘I should’ve left active duty for the Reserves at the 12-year point (when we started a family and my career priorities changed). The money would’ve worked out about the same, and we would’ve reached financial independence within a year or two of when we did, but our quality of life would’ve been way better.”’

This is what I wrestle with the most. I dread the slog that years 12 through 20 will bring and the separation it will cause from my family. Can you expound on that, or point to a place you have already expounded on these statements?

Specifically: How would the money have worked out the same in the Reserves vs active duty?

This is what I struggle with. Monthly drill pay would hardly prove comparable to my current active duty compensation, and I know little of what other opportunities might be available.”

One of the reasons I write is to help today’s servicemembers avoid my mistakes – or at least anticipate them. Yet, this post wasn’t based on my experience alone but also on 15 years of forum threads and reader e-mails.

Let me start by agreeing that people should stay on active duty as long as they find it challenging and fulfilling. When the fun stops, though, then it’s time to think about leaving active duty for the Reserves or National Guard.

A couple of clarifications:

  • There will be no doubt in your mind when the fun has stopped. It’s different for everyone, but you’ll know it when you see it.
  • Consider going from active duty to the Reserves or the National Guard before going straight to civilian life. The Reserve/Guard is an intermediate step toward work/life balance, with more of the things you enjoy(ed) about the military and less of the not-so-enjoyable parts. Readers tell me it’s easier to go this way than to go total civilian and later try to affiliate with a Reserve/Guard unit. Try a drill billet for a while, and then decide if you want to go civilian.

Tip #1: Stay on Active Duty Service As Long As It’s Challenging and Fulfilling

1990 on USS NEW YORK CITY (SSN 696)

Not everyone should just leave active duty service for the sake of leaving a possibly taxing job. Some still find it challenging and fulfilling. In that case, there’s nothing wrong with staying on active duty. 

Personally, I enjoyed my first 10 years of active duty. After my second submarine, my dual-military spouse and I wanted to stay in Pearl Harbor. I could’ve taken just about any career-enhancing billet (as long as it was Nuclear Power School instructor or BUPERS), but we wanted collocation. There seemed to be plenty of billets in Hawaii, and we weren’t interested in moving thousands of miles just for the job. Again.

I took the first Pearl Harbor vacancy that came up at my rotation date: shore duty on an admiral’s staff. I didn’t appreciate that Ops & Plans was a 60-hour/week deadline-fueled job, and I wouldn’t have cared because, after sea duty, every other billet seems like a paid vacation. But, we were perpetually overwhelmed by real-world crises with submarine missions or by the inevitable paperwork crisis du jour (no PowerPoint back then– only Lotus Freelance). Even message traffic was largely screened by hand and routed in paper.

We also started our family when starting shore duty, which meant we encountered sleep deprivation (in a good parenting way) at home as well as at work. We were overwhelmed on the domestic front too.

Tip #2: Learn About Changing from Active Duty to the Reserves

Take time to ask about the Reserve component from other service members. I was surrounded by Navy Reserve officers on the staff. Some of them were full-time civil-service employees, while others were contractors, and I’d occasionally see them in uniform for active duty or drill weekends.

One of the Reservists on our staff had even been a shipmate on our first submarine. I asked them a few questions about their billets, pay, and pensions, yet I never really made the time to learn about the system. My spouse was working alongside Reservists too, but we only saw them once a year for their two weeks of active duty.

To be fair, the Reserves were a minority of the staff. Our commands were also filled with active-duty junior servicemembers who were separating at 8-12 years of service and older ones who were retiring at 20-30 years. I identified much more with those groups than the Reservists.

However, take some time to learn more about the service requirements of Reservists. For example, some Guard and Reserve units offer the traditional one weekend a month, two weeks a year, while other units may have more opportunities for picking up extra days or mobilizations.

Compare Active Duty Retirement and Reserve Retirement

It’s also important to understand how the pay retirement benefits work. If I’d made the mental bandwidth to analyze my options then, I would’ve eventually realized that Reserve pensions are based on the pay tables in effect when the pension starts. They’re not based on the pay tables in effect when you apply for retirement.

By federal law 10 U.S. Code section 1407(d)(1)(a), the pension’s length of service would have also been at the maximum pay scale in retirement rank, not just the years of service when a Reserve/Guard member applied to retire. That’s also in the Financial Management Regulation (DoD 7000.14-R) section 030205.A.2.

I didn’t understand any of that at the time.

Surprisingly, those pension facts are not widely understood even among today’s Reserve and Guard servicemembers. Read this article on National Guard and Reserve retirement benefits for a full overview of how retiring from the Guard and Reserves works, how it impacts your pay, which benefits you are eligible for, gray area benefits, and more.

Tip #3: Invest and Save More for Retirement

In today’s military retirement ecosystem, there are options for you to save money. For example, the Blended Retirement System involves TSP accounts and a government matching component. However, if you’re in the Reserves or National Guard working as a full-time civilian, at an installment or as a contractor, you should consider creating a budget that allows you to save additional money beyond your retirement plan. There’s nothing wrong with having a little more money set aside for either a rainy day or, better yet, the golden years of your life. 

When I was younger, I was familiar with inflation and healthcare expenses, but I didn’t make the time to learn how the Reserve pension handled those issues. I thought that if I retired from the Reserves in my 40s, then my pension (at age 60) would’ve been eroded by two decades of inflation.

I didn’t see any value in the Reserves and I certainly wasn’t going to leave my “safe” active-duty career. I was grossly wrong, and if I’d talked with enough Reservists, I would finally have figured out my errors. However, I had my active-duty blinders on and didn’t see any other path.

If I’d joined the Reserves, I would’ve drilled until 20 total Good Years (active combined with  Reserve) to earn the pension. I would have had an inflation-fighting pension (and Tricare) at age 60 instead of at age 41. The Reserve pension would’ve been about 70% of my active-duty pension, and our savings and investments would only have needed to bridge (at worst) a 19-year gap. If I were a drilling Reserve/Guard member today, I would’ve also had Tricare Reserve Select. 

After that, when I “retired awaiting pay,” I would have bought Tricare Reserve Retired until age 60. Reserve retirement also solves the same issues handled by an active-duty pension, and I would only have had to fill in the financial planning holes with other paid employment.

In retrospect, a “real job” would’ve been straightforward – even easy. I didn’t know it back then, but like many Pearl Harbor submariners, when I showed up at my drill weekends, I would’ve eventually been offered a contractor or civil-service job on that same staff as a tactical development officer. I would’ve had other opportunities to go back on active duty for 30-179 days at the submarine staff or Pacific Fleet headquarters or PACOM.

On the civilian side of it, I would have networked with my shipmates for nuclear work at a shipyard or an electrical utility career at HECO. I could have used my graduate degree to teach at local high schools or colleges and could’ve easily moved into state or federal civil service systems. I’m confident about this because those are the same job offers I received when I retired from active duty, and a lot of the offers came through those same Reservists.

Yet, I was suffering from the “military inferiority complex.” The Cold War had ended and we were all scrambling to keep our jobs during the largest drawdown since WWII. (The staff was rightly concerned that submarine missions would be suspended and the force cut to less than a third of its size.) I thought that I was worthless and weak and that I would never be able to make it in a civilian career. I feared that I’d never get hired by anyone for anything and would end up fixing leaky toilets.

I was not just ignorant about the Reserves and National Guard but also about building a civilian career. At that chronically-fatigued time in my life, the fog of work made it easier to keep dragging my sorry butt into the staff’s classified concrete bunker to either scramble a submarine or write a point paper, or both with bonus points for doing it on Sunday morning.

Today, I know that within five years after leaving active duty, my total compensation (Reserve/Guard drills + civilian earnings) would’ve been higher than my active-duty pay and benefits. The first couple of years would have been a big dip in paychecks and a huge disruption on the homefront, but my wife and I would’ve figured it out. We would’ve kept about the same expenses, eventually recovered our savings rate, and had a much higher quality of life.

Sure, life would have still been complicated. My active-duty spouse might have been sent on an unaccompanied tour to Diego Garcia. I might have been mobilized to support contingency operations in Kosovo or the Middle East, certainly after 9/11. I might have struggled to figure out what I wanted to do with my life as the Navy bounced my spouse from one homeport to another. We might even have had to leave Hawaii for a few years (Guam! Japan!). But would Reserve life have been as stressful as the dual-military active-duty life that we dealt with for another decade?

Active Duty vs. Reserve

How did I (finally) learn all about the Reserves? Why do I know more about the pay and benefits today than most servicemembers?

We learned all of these details when (a year before I retired) my spouse hit a career speedbump and left active duty for the Reserves. Our life immediately got awesome. Better yet, her unit was full of Reserve submariners who happily explained to me the lifestyle that I’d missed out on during the back half of my active-duty career. Then, they offered me jobs with their civilian employers.

Today, I’ve been retired from active duty for over 15 years, and I’m still getting a job offer every year or two – and these offers are coming from outside of my robust network of personal finance bloggers and entrepreneurs.

That’s when I started reading everything I could find about Reserve pensions and benefits. When I realized how the pension actually worked, I knew that gutting it out to 20 on active duty had been a mistake.

My spouse and I also overshot the mark on our finances when we persevered for the active-duty pension. We were saving for financial independence long before those marketing guys wrote The Millionaire Next Door (another classic that took a few years to gain traction during the Internet decade).

That was also years before those researchers at Trinity University replicated Bengen’s results and popularized the 4% Safe Withdrawal Rate. I placed too much value on an active-duty pension when a Reserve pension would have accomplished “enough” of the inflation adjustment and the health insurance.

Final Thoughts

With what I know now, I could’ve worked part-time for a few extra years to build up the same investments and continued to drill for a Reserve pension instead of full-time with the 60-hour weeks to get an active-duty pension. We would have reached financial independence (at 25 x expenses) a few years later but at a half-marathon pace instead of a 1,500-meter sprint.

Maybe I wouldn’t have worked those few extra years after all. In the early 2000s (as we were approaching a delayed financial independence), I would’ve learned more about this blogging fad and created a part-time income of $20K/year. We would have lost less money on buying real estate during active duty and might’ve invested in a few dirt-cheap rental properties.

We would’ve had more quality family time together.

But back then, I didn’t see the possibilities, let alone the opportunities. I was too focused on gutting it out to 20 for that cliff-vesting pension. I was clenching my jaw (and grinding my teeth) to deal with the daily pressure (and I have the medical records to prove it).

Today, at age 57, I’d happily trade a million dollars of our net worth to recover the lost time of my 30s spent in overtime.

The Reserves and National Guard offer similar challenges and fulfillment of active duty but with less of the sucky parts of active duty. Work/life balance is still complicated, but there’s less stress (physically, mentally, & emotionally) and there’s less time in the field. There are still deployments, but they’re at a slower cycle, perhaps one out of five instead of every other year. Even that’s negotiable during peacetime, based on your career priorities and federal funding.

If you have a traditional civilian career, then once a month, you’ll work 12 straight days around the drill weekend, but that’s still a lower operating tempo than active duty.

Reserve service members near a four-star staff command might find more opportunities for active-duty orders. Large staffs are chronically short-handed (and on short notice) while you’re a Reservist. Right there. And ready to work. A phone call on Thursday asking if you want a Saturday midwatch? Yeah, we could handle that. I got those calls on active duty anyway.

For some servicemembers, the National Guard might be a better deal than the Reserves. National Guard armories are generally closer to home, especially for drill weekends, and there are opportunities for state-funded orders as well as federal ones. Instead of traveling hundreds of miles to Reserve centers, you might network with local Guard members for civilian contractor gigs or even full-time employment. Some Guard billets work with state civil service and government staff.

When you’re saving for financial independence during active duty (instead of living a consumer lifestyle), then your rising net worth gives you choices. You don’t have to fear unemployment. You’ll have time to network (real life as well as Linkedin) and learn about civilian careers. It’s never been easier to freelance the gig economy or to (eventually) start your own business.

You have skills. You can make the finances work. You don’t have to live in fear.

Now, you should track down those Reserve & Guard members in your area (of any rank) and learn how they do it.

Even if you’re still feeling challenged and fulfilled by active duty today, it’s worth learning about the alternatives now. Someday, you’ll slam into a billet where you’re too overwhelmed (and too exhausted) to figure out your transition. You’ll get the “unrefuseable offer” from the chain of command or your assignment officer. When (not if) that happens, you won’t have a lot of time to figure things out, and you may be too tired to tackle the research.

Better yet, when you’re saving for financial independence, you’ll have choices.

The best time to save for financial independence was yesterday. The second-best time to save is today. 

Military Guide to Financial Independence

This book provides servicemembers, veterans, and their families with a critical roadmap for becoming financially independent. Topics include:
  • Military pension
  • TSP
  • Tricare Health System
  • & More

The post Transitioning from Active Duty to Reserves Or National Guard appeared first on The Military Wallet.

]]>
https://themilitarywallet.com/leave-active-duty-for-reserves/feed/ 74
IRR Military Retirement https://themilitarywallet.com/retire-from-irr/ https://themilitarywallet.com/retire-from-irr/#comments Sat, 02 Oct 2021 03:23:00 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=17562 It’s possible to earn retirement points in the Individual Ready Reserve (IRR) but it isn’t easy. We’ll cover how earning points in the IRR works and discuss the differences between the IRR and Retired Reserve.

The post IRR Military Retirement appeared first on The Military Wallet.

]]>
When you leave active duty, you may have the option of transferring into the Individual Ready Reserve (IRR). The IRR provides the military with a source of trained servicemembers who are on call if the military needs to expand rapidly. Most servicemembers remain in the IRR while completing their initial Military Service Obligation (MSO) and then separate.

In some cases, members decide to remain in the IRR beyond their MSO and achieve the last points needed to retire from the Guard or Reserves.

Achieving military retirement as an IRR member can be complex, and understanding how to earn retirement points is crucial. This guide offers detailed insights and tips to help you achieve your retirement benefits through effective management of IRR point-earning opportunities.

Let’s dive in. 

Does IRR time count towards retirement?

Yes, IRR time counts towards retirement from the Guard or Reserves; however, you have fewer opportunities to earn points than Reservists on active or drilling duty. Additionally, the rules for how IRR time counts towards retirement can vary depending on your branch of service and specific circumstances. 

How to Earn Retirement Points in the IRR

You need to accumulate 20 “good years” of service to receive a Reserve pension. Simply put, a “good year” is a qualifying year in which you earn at least 50 points for retirement. 

IRR point earning opportunities vary by branch, and all the opportunities you have are unpaid. In other words, in the IRR, you are drilling for points only. 

In general, you can earn points in the IRR by doing the following: 

  • Inactive Duty Training (IDT) in a non-pay training status
  • Active Duty for Special Work (ADSW)
  • Active Duty for Training (ADT)
  • Completing correspondence courses
  • Attending annual musters

In the IRR, you automatically earn 15 participation points each year. To successfully earn your participation points, you must attend the annual muster, complete a yearly readiness screening and respond to all official military correspondence. Failure to do any of these tasks can affect your point earning and benefits. 

On top of that, you can earn one point a day for any active duty assignment and one point for each 4-hour period of IDT completed. For IDT, you can earn a maximum of 2 points per day. 

You can apply for ADSW and ADT with a DA Form 1058. Most IRR members earn points by completing correspondence courses, but they are not always easy to come by and you may be required to drive for some of those opportunities. 

Keep in mind that distance learning opportunities also vary by military service.

Reader Question: Can I get promoted in the IRR?

An important thing to consider is whether you can be promoted in the IRR. Servicemembers have to serve in a pay grade for a certain amount of time before they can be promoted or retire at that grade. This is known as Time in Grade (TIG), and it only counts toward promotion requirements when you earn a good year. 

Officers in the pay grades of O-1 through O-3 need to serve at least six months in that grade for retirement. On the other hand, some officers have to serve a requirement of 3 years in grade.  

Let’s review a reader question on the topic to give you an idea of how this could work out in real-time. 

A reader writes:

Hello sir! I’m an O-5 (USNR) with 19 years and I stumbled upon your website/blog. All I can say is AWESOME! You put things in plain English when many other websites and instructions either “beat around the bush” or use vernacular that usually leads to more questions! BZ! I was hoping you could answer one question for me. Since I am at 19 years in the Navy (seven years active / 12 years Reserve) – I am trying to weigh my options when I go over 20.

After I hit 20, if I am on the O-6 promotion list and then immediately choose to transfer to the IRR, would I be able to retire as a CAPT? Would I have to serve as a CAPT for at least three years in the IRR and if I earn enough points for a good year, does that mean I could eventually “retire awaiting pay” and retire as an O-6? I guess that was a long-winded way of asking: can you be promoted to O-6 in the IRR and earn good years in the IRR?

Thanks! 

The answer to your question is that while it’s possible for officers to be eligible for promotion in the IRR, it’s rare. There are too many Reservists on mobilization and drilling status that typically get precedence for promotion. It would be better to keep drilling (or mobilizing) at least until you reach 20 years and get selected for O-6. 

Once you’re selected for O-6, you can transfer to the IRR whenever you want (even before you’re formally promoted.) O-6s usually need three years to meet TIG requirements, but you can also request a waiver to reduce the TIG requirement to two years. That’s routinely approved for most retirements and would almost certainly be approved for retirement from the IRR during a drawdown.

If you decide to go to the IRR, you can earn points toward retirement by taking correspondence courses, signing up for special duty (funeral detail), or by other individual arrangements with your chain of command. (You may also want to see if you can earn points by serving as a U.S. Naval Academy Blue & Gold Officer.) 

Just keep in mind that Time in Grade only counts when you earn a good year.

Retired Reserve vs. IRR

The “Retired Reserve” is another term used for gray area retirement, which refers to Reserve members who have achieved eligibility for National Guard/Reserve retirement but haven’t yet reached age 60. The Retired Reserve is not the same as the Individual Ready Reserve. 

Let’s take a look at how the Retired Reserve compares to the IRR: 

Retired ReserveIndividual Ready Reserve
Training Members do not participate in regular training but can be recalled to active duty in times of war or national emergency. Members do not participate in regular training but can be recalled to active duty during war or national emergency. 
Subject to RecallRetired Reserve would typically be called to duty after IRR members.IRR would likely be called to duty before the Retired Reserve.
Point AccrualMembers no longer earn points, but seniority within grade accrues. Members can still accumulate points toward retirement.
Access to HealthcareRetired Reserve members have access to Tricare Retired Reserve. IRR members do not qualify for military health benefits unless activated. 
Access to Base BenefitsCommissary, Exchange, Travel and Lodging, Morale, Wealthfare and Recreation (MWR)Commissary, Exchange, Travel and Lodging, MWR 

Leaving active duty or Reserve status to join the IRR is a big decision, and it may not be easy (or possible) to revert to your prior duty status.

Here are a few things you should consider before deciding between the IRR and the Retired Reserve. 

Dual Status in the Reserves 

There are many opportunities for dual status in the Guard and Reserves, including dual status military technician status. A dual status member often refers to a service member who holds both a civilian position and a military position within the National Guard or Reserve forces. This term is most commonly used to describe Reserve Component technicians who are federal civilian employees required to maintain membership in the Reserve Component as a condition of their employment.

An example of a dual status technician could be an aircraft mechanic who works as a Title 32 Technician during the week and serves as a Guardsman or Reservist in a part-time military status.

Transitioning into a dual status military technician job may also allow you to buy back your military service credits, which would accelerate your civilian retirement while still maintaining your Reserve pension. It’s the best of both worlds.

In the Reserves, Longevity Accrues During “Retired Awaiting Pay”

A great advantage of retiring from the Reserves is that if you qualify for gray area retirement, your seniority in that grade will continue to accrue as if you were on active duty.

When your Reserve or Guard pension starts, it’s calculated using the longevity that would have accrued in your rank if you had been on active duty between the time you filed for “retired awaiting pay” and the time your pension started.

Note the phrase “retired awaiting pay.” It means you’ve transferred to the Retired Reserve until your pension starts. That’s the normal retirement status for over 99% of Guard and Reserve retirees. That status is why your rank’s longevity continues to accrue in “retired awaiting pay” status, and it’s the reason that your pension uses the pay tables in effect when your pension starts. 

Members who are “retired awaiting pay” are subject to recall in a national emergency, but this is rare. Members can avoid being subject to recall by requesting a discharge instead of transferring to the Retired Reserve. However, when your pension starts (normally at age 60), it would be calculated at the tables in effect on the date of your discharge, and it would be calculated at your longevity at discharge. In other words, your pension would have been frozen at the date you retired (discharged) and not boosted for inflation or longevity.

You Don’t Get Tricare in the IRR

When you’re a drilling Reserve/Guard member, you’re eligible for Tricare Reserve Select (TRS) but if you transfer to the IRR—even for a single day— you lose your Tricare health coverage. 

If you’re deciding between the Retired Reserve and the IRR you should know that the Retired Reserve has access to the Tricare Retired Reserve (TRR) plan, but the monthly premiums are much more expensive than TRS. 

You may be able to find equivalent coverage through a Marketplace (Affordable Care Act) plan, but it will likely be more expensive than TRS or have much higher deductibles. 

Healthcare should not be the only reason that you stay in a drill billet, but if you’re going to leave that billet, then you should make sure you have another source of health insurance.

Reader Question: Is retirement from the IRR worth it? 

A National Guard member emailed and asked:

sitting at nearly a decade in the Army National Guard with around 1900 retirement points. I have a few months left before deciding to resign, transfer to the IRR, or stay in a drill billet.

Is it worth staying in the IRR for another 10 years to earn a military retirement?

Maybe the question is simpler than I’m making it. But for this to work, I would need 50 retirement points a year for the next 10 years, something that could be accomplished through 150 hours of distance learning annually.

10 years * 50 points/year = 500 points

500 points * 3 hours DL/point = 1500 hours of distance learning in the next 10 years.

This is a great question. For starters, you’ll be relieved to learn that you’re awarded an automatic 15 “participation points” per year in the IRR. So technically, you’ll only need to earn 35 points to get a good year.

Retiring from the IRR can happen. But it isn’t easy. In the best-case scenario, you will only need to complete a couple of years in order to earn your retirement from the IRR, but you will need to aggressively chase your points.

As an IRR member, no one will follow up with you to ensure you meet your goals. You become your only advocate and cheerleader, and earning a good year becomes your responsibility to yourself. Most servicemembers find it easier to earn a good year while still affiliated with a drilling Guard or Reserve unit, as a member of the Individual Mobilized Augmentee (IMA), a special section of the Reserves.

Military Guide to Financial Independence

This book provides servicemembers, veterans, and their families with a critical roadmap for becoming financially independent. Topics include:
  • Military pension
  • TSP
  • Tricare Health System
  • & More

The post IRR Military Retirement appeared first on The Military Wallet.

]]>
https://themilitarywallet.com/retire-from-irr/feed/ 80
What Does USAA’s Investment Business Sale Mean for You https://themilitarywallet.com/usaa-victory-capital-schwab/ https://themilitarywallet.com/usaa-victory-capital-schwab/#comments Sun, 28 Feb 2021 23:35:00 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=17447 USAA sold its investment businesses to Victory Capital and Schwab in July 2019 and is now a Victory Capital Investment Franchise. Here's how it affects you as a customer.

The post What Does USAA’s Investment Business Sale Mean for You appeared first on The Military Wallet.

]]>
USAA’s investment management business recently changed ownership. USAA serves 13 million members, employs nearly 37,000 people, and has a net worth of $30 billion, so this was a significant transaction. Despite these big numbers, USAA was still considered small in the world of financial services companies. That, as much as anything, was a driving factor for the sale.

Here’s what you need to know about how that might affect your relationship with USAA.

When did USAA sell to Victory Capital?

USAA sold its investment businesses to Victory Capital and Schwab in July 2019 and is now a Victory Capital Investment Franchise. Under terms of the agreement, Victory Capital acquired USAA Asset Management Company for $850 million, plus the opportunity for additional contingent payments based on future business performance

Let’s analyze how that affects your plans for financial independence.

The sale of the Asset Management Company includes USAA’s mutual funds, exchange-traded funds, and 529 accounts. It closed in 2019 and Victory expects to finish moving the accounts over to their systems during 2020.

The Investment Management Company includes USAA’s brokerage and managed-portfolio accounts. The sale of USAA’s wealth-management business to Schwab is expected to close later in 2020.

Why would USAA sell these assets, why are these companies buying them, and what’s going to happen to your fund shares?

Consider this. USAA’s investment managers were competing with companies that manage at least 10x the clients and a thousand times as much money. USAA’s fixed expenses were spread over a much smaller base. For every $1 of fixed expenses that the gigantic corporations spent per client dollars, USAA was paying over $1000 of members’ money. Eventually (sooner rather than later) that was creating a business model that was unsustainable.

Over the years I’ve spoken with USAA’s managers about their investment business, and I’ve attended USAA’s annual influencer conferences since 2011.

I’ve also interviewed Matt Dennis, the Chief of Staff & Director of Investor Relations at Victory Capital.

When the Schwab sale completes its regulatory review then I’ll talk with them as well.

The Bottom Line:

Your shares in USAA-branded funds still belong to you, and now the funds are run by Victory Capital. If you’ve signed up for USAA’s wealth-management services, then Schwab will manage your investments for you.

Members do not need to take action on their accounts.

The new firms have much more experience (and size) than USAA would ever have achieved with lower expenses. After the transitions, Victory Capital and Schwab expect to handle these funds better than USAA. That’s a great financial deal for the account holders, although it might change your original reasons for investing with USAA.

USAA made an outstanding move for its members who use the company’s other products & services. After nearly four decades with them, I’m glad to see the new focus on its core insurance and banking. They have a long way to go (I’m lookin’ at you, banking) but the company is heading in a better direction.

All net proceeds from this transaction directly benefit members, not the bottom line. For example, after deal closing and account conversion, USAA improved the competitiveness of its banking and insurance products, and distributed an appropriate amount as part of the annual member distribution process in 2019.

This post will review who benefits, and then we’ll discuss your options.

USAA’s corporate policy

A good deal for the members!

A good deal for the members!

The company offers trust, consolidation, and convenience to its members– for life.

During the last 20 years, USAA has refined another financial core value:

Every product and service has to pay for itself.

This is very different from the rest of the financial industry.

USAA doesn’t use subsidies or loss leaders. They don’t run deficits to gain market share. If one of their divisions wants to boost its insurance program or a credit-card business, then it has to grow it from cashflow or spend its own funds (up front) to make it happen.

We members are paying only for the things we actually use, including prudent risk management. That keeps our premiums lower.

During the decade that I’ve attended USAA conferences, the company has piloted dozens of products and services… and killed off many of them. Even their research center has to make money for the company. (They license their patents.) A few new products were very popular with some of the members but they cost more than those members were paying for their benefits. The rest of us members would have had to subsidize those products or services with our higher fees.

USAA is a private company that doesn’t have to satisfy Wall Street institutions or retail investors. It serves its members, and we pay the operating expenses. I’m happy with USAA’s vehicle insurance because I know that I’m not paying extra to subsidize the launch of their latest life insurance policies… or their mutual funds.

I’m especially happy that USAA plans to “distribute an appropriate amount in the annual member distribution process.”

USAA’s motives for selling to Victory Capital and Schwab

USAA just couldn’t compete in the investment business. Believe it or not, they’re too small.

USAA has over 13 million members, and 1.5 million of them had invested billions of dollars in their fund shares.

That small minority of the members bought funds through USAA’s investment services. An even tinier fraction of the membership paid USAA’s wealth managers to handle their investments for them.

Meanwhile USAA was competing with companies who manage trillions of dollars for tens of millions of account owners. BlackRock, Vanguard, Fidelity, and Schwab aren’t just handling more members and assets than USAA. They’re orders of magnitude bigger.

USAA has struggled with this investment scale for years. In 2014, they hired National Financial Services to run their brokerage infrastructure. NFS is a subsidiary of Fidelity Investments. USAA was trying to minimize its fixed expenses (by outsourcing to a world-class back-office contractor) while boosting member services with its own world-class managers.

The business model was unsustainable. USAA could have invested additional hundreds of millions of our member dollars to boost their efficiency (and attract more investors), but it would have been a waste of money. USAA is one of America’s best insurance companies, but they couldn’t outspend (let alone outgrow) the investment industry’s behemoths.

I think USAA has burned through enough member money to find the solutions. It’s time for someone else to deal with the issues.

USAA could have shut down their accounts and funds and returned the cash to their owners. (The financial industry does this all the time with struggling mutual funds.) However, USAA had already spent hundreds of millions of dollars to build those divisions and could recover some of it for the members.

The value of USAA’s investment businesses

New ownership.

Victory Capital manages mutual funds. Over the last six years, they’ve bought the funds from 11 other small investment companies and they manage them for the investors who buy the fund shares.

VC won’t collect management fees from USAA– they earn them from the people who own the shares. Victory gets its owner’s profits from scale and efficiency. The company’s fixed expenses are spread out over many more investment funds, and Victory has paid for the enterprise-class systems to squeeze out the excess costs. In addition, the company consolidates their buy & sell orders for the assets in all of their funds. Their size means that they also get better prices on their trades in the actively-managed funds.

USAA’s mutual funds are tiny in comparison to the rest of the industry. That helps make them nimble, but it’s expensive. Actively-managed funds have much higher research & trading costs than index funds, and expense ratios of 0.5%-1.3% are all too common for an active fund. Meanwhile, passive index funds have expense ratios of 0.03%-0.20%.

As an example, USAA’s Cornerstone Aggressive fund (UCAGX) has an expense ratio of 1.21% to invest roughly $300M. If Victory Capital can reduce that to 1.00% then they’ll save 0.20%– over $600K per year. Some of the savings can go to the fund’s shareholders as a higher return, too.

USAA has 74 actively-managed funds. Every one of them has the same problem of small size and higher expenses.

Victory can solve these problems, and they’re big enough to do it well. You can read more at Victory Capital’s annual report.

The value of military clients

“Oh, you’re in the military?”

USAA’s members are also valuable to companies like Victory Capital and Schwab. Those firms want to attract more military clients.

America’s military population is over 60 million servicemembers, veterans, families, and immediate relatives. 13 million of those people are USAA members, yet only about 2.5 million of them own investment accounts through USAA. Nearly 11 million more USAA members could shop at Victory Capital and Schwab and then those companies could sell to millions more.

Victory will market USAA’s fund brand to another 58 million people with a military affiliation. If they attract just 2-3 million new shareholders then they’ll spread their fixed expenses among twice as many people.

What’s in it for you?

If you’ve bought shares in any USAA mutual funds or ETFs, you’re still the owner of those shares. If you have any investment accounts with USAA (including 529s, IRAs, and taxable brokerage accounts) then you’re still the owner of those accounts.

Let’s answer some of the other member questions.

The funds still have the same USAA brand name. (Victory Capital paid a high price for that brand and the shareholders.) Victory is just the new owner, and they have the tools to reduce the expenses for their clients.

If you’re using USAA’s brokerage, or if you’ve signed up for their portfolio management service, that will be handled by Schwab. You still own the accounts and the money in them, and Schwab has the scale and experience to reduce your expenses there too.

All USAA members benefit from the sales to Victory and Schwab. By the end of 2020, USAA will have a new focus on insurance and banking– without trying to handle an investment branch. There might even be a little extra distribution in the Subscriber Accounts.

In March, Victory’s Investor Relations department reached out to me and I asked for an interview. On 13 April I spoke with Matt Dennis, the Chief of Staff & Director of Investor Relations.

He says that Victory’s CEO is moving the majority of the company’s staff to San Antonio. (USAA’s headquarters has been there for decades.) Their new office of 120 people will include about 50 of USAA’s member service representatives who moved over to Victory as part of the sale of the asset management company. Victory’s back-office operations will stay in Ohio (about 80 people), and another 160 employees are spread across the country in smaller franchise offices.

Victory is already reducing the expenses of USAA’s funds. They’re waiving fulcrum fees during the next year. However, there’s a long way to go on the high expense ratios of the actively-managed USAA funds.

Mr. Dennis says that Victory is also boosting customer service without passing on expenses to their clients. Investors in USAA funds can continue to invest through Victory (with direct sales of their funds) without having to open a brokerage account. All of Victory’s call-center employees are licensed representatives, and members can also ask to speak with a certified financial planner. (USAA has struggled for a few years with this part of member service.) Victory’s CFPs offer free reviews of clients’ accounts to recommend asset allocations and discuss other changes.

Both USAA and Victory are beefing up their website security with wider two-factor authentication and other new infrastructure. (Cyberattacks are a bigger concern than ever, and every major investment firm in the country is enhancing their security.) The cybersecurity branches of both companies are unlikely to let members log in to their accounts through each other’s servers.

Mr. Dennis quickly pointed out that you can always see your USAA fund shares by linking them to USAA’s website or Personal Capital or other financial dashboard aggregator apps. That keeps the “consolidation” benefit.

To manage those shares, however, USAA members who invest in USAA funds will eventually have to log in to a Victory Capital account or call USAA’s toll-free number to be connected with Victory’s call center (or call a Victory phone number directly). This reduces USAA’s “convenience” benefit.

Mr. Dennis promised that Victory Capital will continue to improve its client communications. The company was too quiet during the transition from USAA, and Victory is working harder on direct-mail and e-mail updates. He said they’re also coordinating with Schwab for USAA’s wealth-management clients who are moving over to Schwab’s systems. Victory already does this with Schwab clients for several other fund companies that Victory has acquired over the years.

Victory will continue its financial literacy programs. (They plan to donate $1M in grants to non-profit financial education groups, including military organizations.) Hopefully, they won’t create yet another financial literacy website, and I’ve encouraged them to reach out to military financial conferences and other groups. Victory can support more non-profits and counselors who are already helping military families pay off debt, boost their budgeting, and grow their wealth.

Pros and Cons of USAA

The change in ownership has enhanced the user experience for USAA members. There continues to be a lot to like about a USAA membership for military personnel.

Pros

Founded 100 years ago by a group of Army officers to provide insurance services. Since that time, it has grown to become one of the top fully integrated financial services organizations in America, offering military members banking, car and homeowners insurance, purchase and refi mortgages, investment advice, credit card services, and a wide range of products and services.

Customer service is placed at a premium and this is reflected in consistently high customer service satisfaction.

For banking services, there are no monthly fee checking and savings accounts, no minimum balance requirements, and no overdraft transfer fees if you opt for overdraft protection.

Your first 10 withdrawals at any of the 60,000 USAA affiliated ATMs are free each month, and all transactions made with any of the 1,200 USAA branded ATMs are also free

USAA refunds up to $15 per month in other banks’ ATM usage fees for transactions at ATMs in the United States.

A highly-rated mobile app is available on Google Play (4.5 stars, 174,000+ ) and App Store (4.8 stars, 1.3 million ratings).

Cons

USAA’s banking is only available to those who have served in the military and their spouses and children. Civilians may take advantage of some of USAA’s insurance services.

Much of USAA’s service is virtual as evidenced by the fact that USAA only has five physical locations in the U.S. Customers needing support will generally have to get it online or over the phone.

Annual percentage yields on investments are competitive, but customers may do better elsewhere. For example, the basic USAA Savings Account has an APY of 0.03% and a minimum opening deposit of $25.

What if you’re unhappy about the sales?

USAA still offers trust, consolidation, and convenience for its members.

You can still trust the USAA brand name on the mutual funds and ETFs, but it’s clear that the majority of USAA members didn’t care about consolidating their investments for convenience.

I’ve heard from several friends and readers who are frustrated with Victory Capital’s transition and communication. (If you’re happy with the transition, then please leave a comment below or contact me!) Victory has committed to improving that.

If you feel that active investing is still the right strategy for your wealth, then give Victory Capital another year to show what it can do. You’ll know it’s working when they reduce the expense ratios of the actively-managed funds.

If you’d still rather pay someone to manage your wealth, then give Schwab a year to prove their skills. They offer world-class service to thousands of investment advisors across the country, and they’ll do the same with their new wealth-management clients from USAA.

If you don’t want to wait for the Schwab acquisition to close, then Schwab will pay you to make the transition on your own. It might seem unbelievable that Schwab will pay up to $500 for you to move now, but it’s a pittance against the total cost of moving over a million of USAA’s wealth-management clients. (Schwab will also recoup some of those payouts from Victory Capital and other fund companies who already pay a revenue share to market USAA funds on Schwab’s systems.) This is one more way to directly reduce your investing expenses.

My spouse and I invested in actively-managed mutual funds in the 1980s and 1990s, and we sure paid the fees for it. We finally recognized the problem at the turn of the century, and we’ve been very happy with index funds since 2004. If you’re no longer happy with active funds then consider USAA’s passively-managed index funds. One of my CFP friends (also a military retiree) likes the 500 Index Reward fund and the Extended Market Index fund.

I’m not going to rehash the perpetual debate of active management versus passive index funds, but I’ll point out that the passive funds will return more than 99% of their benchmark’s performance for extraordinarily low expenses and taxes… and far less of your effort at picking the funds or managers. They’re very cheap for Victory Capital to run, and they’ll probably reduce their expense ratios as they attract more military clients and grow the funds.

If you’re not happy with wealth management from Schwab after getting your $500 incentive then… that’s a tough problem to solve. Schwab has some of the biggest and best operations for the industry’s lowest fees, and if their wealth managers can’t keep you happy then it might be time to change your investment style.

You could search for fee-only advisors through NAPFA, the Garrett Network, or the XY Planning Network. Consider advisors who only charge for specific tasks or projects, with no commissions or other upsells. You can also read about Harry Sit’s advice-only search service to locate advisors who will help you set up your investments and let them run in autopilot. It’s a lot cheaper than typical wealth managers, and it might turn out that you don’t need as much of the management part.

If you’re curious about taking charge of your investments (and automating them) then you can learn more at the trustworthy and objective Bogleheads Wiki, or contact me with questions.

Your Call To Action

If you were a client with USAA investment funds or wealth management, then what’s your plan? Please use the comments to tell us what you’re going to do.

Is USAA Still Good?

If anything, the change in ownership and commitment to enhancing services makes USAA an even better bet for many service members. It has always been a financial institution serving a transient population, so USAA has also always been on the cutting edge of financial technology, and this, teamed with legendary customer service, continues to make it an attractive choice for service members in many ways.

Military Guide to Financial Independence

This book provides servicemembers, veterans, and their families with a critical roadmap for becoming financially independent. Topics include:
  • Military pension
  • TSP
  • Tricare Health System
  • & More

The post What Does USAA’s Investment Business Sale Mean for You appeared first on The Military Wallet.

]]>
https://themilitarywallet.com/usaa-victory-capital-schwab/feed/ 105
How Do You Survive A Stock Market Crash? https://themilitarywallet.com/survive-stock-market-crash/ https://themilitarywallet.com/survive-stock-market-crash/#comments Fri, 10 Sep 2021 23:35:00 +0000 https://themilitarywallet.com/?p=17535 Watching your investment portfolio decrease in value is scary. These tips can help you learn how to successfully navigate a stock market crash.

The post How Do You Survive A Stock Market Crash? appeared first on The Military Wallet.

]]>
A reader writes:

“Hi Nords, I have some fears about a market crash that would derail early retirement. If I retire now in my late 40s, it would be near impossible to get my job back in my line of work. It’s almost easier to retire even earlier… Because then one would not be too old to re-enter the workplace.

You’re right about extreme early retirement. I know several early retirees in their 30s (and one in their 20s) who are confident that they’ll be able to freelance their way to more income if they need to. But if you can accumulate the assets to retire early, you might always produce income through some entrepreneurial project.

My spouse and I have been through two “market crashes” during our early retirement: the tech recession of 2001-02 and the Great Recession of 2008-09. We’ve invested since the late 1970s, but both retirement recessions felt more painful because we were no longer covering our expenses with a paycheck. Today, though, we have the experience and confidence born of the crucible. Another recession wouldn’t bother us much, but we might find excellent investment bargains.

Fear

The biggest challenge of a recession is dealing with emotions: particularly fear. The first coping defense for your emotions is an asset allocation that helps you sleep at night. (Then you can lie in bed reciting the Bogleheads mantra “Stay the course!” until you doze off.)

But seriously, watching your portfolio meltdown through a recession is a test of mental toughness and stamina.

Can You Recover From a Stock Market Crash?

In a word, “yes,” you can.

The variables are the length of time it takes and how well you recover. Also, understand that the longer you’re in the market, the more you learn. That applies to your successes and your failures.

In other words, if you’ve been through a stock market crash before, you’ll learn lots of valuable things that will lessen the pain if and when it happens again.

It’s somewhat arbitrary to define what a stock market crash is, but to put things into perspective if the S&P 500 drops 7% in a single day, trading may be halted for 15 minutes. This is the equivalent of calling a time out to allow cooler heads to prevail.

Individual stocks are often halted based on news that impacts a company’s stock price (i.e., a bad earnings report, etc.), but the entire market has only been halted a few times in its entire history. In most cases, the market moves 1-2% at most in a single day.

In general, market crashes are emotional and, most of the time, reasonably short-lived. Understand that financial markets that are usually rational can behave irrationally, often based on world events such as the threat of war, economic news, and so forth.

Overall, the U.S. stock market has proven remarkably resilient in the long term. It routinely recovers from short-term crises and moves higher over extended time frames.

For example, from 1940 through 2020, the S&P Index has produced an average annualized return of more than 11%.

The key to recovering from a market crash is not to panic. Staying invested during crisis periods may seem counterintuitive, but it always turns out to be the best play.

How to Prepare for a Market Crash

There are several proactive steps you can take to minimize the impacts of a market crash on your assets.

Asset Allocation

When you have an asset allocation plan, you can feel as if you’re in control.

When you rebalance during a recession, you’ll end up buying more bargains at the bottom of the market. That confidence keeps you from panicking and selling out at the worst time.

When done the right way, diversification can insulate you in most instances. You can work with a financial advisor based on your investment and allocation goals. You may want to go with a “set it and forget it” strategy such as investing in a target-date retirement fund, as many 401(k) plans allow you to do, or using a robo-advisor where diversification is built in.

If you like to invest on your own, you MUST do your homework and adjust as you go along. But be careful not to get antsy and overcompensate based on short-term events. The best investing is done long-term and without panic.

Recession Investing

A second defense is educating yourself about asset allocation and recession investing. It’s more than merely following directions from a few excellent websites or books– it’s understanding some of the principles behind the advice and appreciating the history of markets.

I started with Dimson & Marsh’s “Triumph of the Optimists” and William Bernstein’s most excellent “The Four Pillars of Investing.” You can browse more books from the “investing” and “retirement” categories on the blog’s “Recommended Reading” list. It doesn’t matter what you read about asset allocation and recession investing as long as you read enough to react “Ho-hum, another swing of the pendulum.” Then turn off CNBC, step away from the computer, and go for a long walk.

Oddly enough, it also helps to share the misery when you’re afraid. One (free) approach is posting to financial independence forums where everyone is worried about the recession. You’ll see some posters buying gold bullion and shotgun shells, but the experienced investors will be waiting for their criteria to rebalance their portfolio.

You’ll also find plenty of reassurance. Other investors hire financial advisors just to have someone to hold their hand and tell them that everything will work out fine.

If you’re so inclined, be ready to buy on the dip. That’s where fortunes can be made over the long term.

Risk Assessment

Everyone has a different tolerance for risk based on several factors. Your age, size of your assets, past investing experiences, and whether or not you invest with the help of a stock advisor or do it on your own are just a few of the variables.

Another part of this is your emotional quotient. Fears and anger can negatively color your investing experiences. Fears and anger can negatively color your investing experiences.

Can you treat investing as a business proposition, or do you get emotionally involved with how your money is invested? Practical and logical approaches work best.

Financial Resources

The next challenge is financial: having the assets to survive a recession. Most recessions bottom out during the first year and start recovering during the second, so my spouse and I keep two years’ expenses in cash.

We begin every January with about 8% of our portfolio in CDs and a money market fund and start spending it on our expenses. At the end of the first year, if the market is up, we replenish the cash stash from dividends/interest or by selling a few appreciated shares.

If the market is down at the end of the first year, we start cashing in the CDs. By the end of the second year, we might have to contemplate selling equity shares, and they might be off their peak value, but we’ve never had to sell at a loss.

Another financial defense against a recession is longevity insurance. Every retirement portfolio should include some annuitized income, even if it’s “just” Social Security. When you reach financial independence, if you do not have a pension, then I strongly recommend creating one for yourself: plan for Social Security or put 20%-25% of your asset allocation in a single-premium index annuity. You’ll get a steady monthly income no matter what the stock market may be doing.

If you’re reluctant to trust an insurance company (and pay the fees for the longevity insurance), then I’d recommend a low-expense dividend equity index fund or a balanced fund, or even rental real estate. (We have a portion of our portfolio in the iShares Select Dividend ETF DVY.)

During the Great Recession, our dividend fund lost nearly two-thirds of its value from peak to trough, but its dividend payouts only shrank about 30% off their peak and then began to recover.

A year later, its share price was back near our cost basis, and it’s risen steadily ever since. (When we rebalanced our portfolio, we bought more shares.) Today it’s above its 2007 levels, but the dividends have grown faster than U.S. inflation (and a lot faster than our inflation!).

Landlords lost equity during the Great Recession but did well on cash flow because many tenants were former homeowners. Other disciplined and diversified dividend investors who held on during recessions (only selling if a company froze or cut its dividend) saw minimal reductions in income.

For even more stability (and less effort), you could buy a balanced fund like Vanguard’s Wellington or Wellesley, which combine both bond income and stock dividends and automatically rebalance their holdings.

Variable Spending

Another financial defense against recessions is variable spending. The 4% Safe Withdrawal Rate withdraws 4% during your first year and then boosts annual withdrawals for inflation every year afterward, but those assumptions are just easier for a computer to simulate. No human robotically follows that system.

Investor behavioral psychology says that the wealth effect inspires us to spend more during bull markets and cut our spending during recessions. If you find yourself tempted to boost your spending during a bull market, then at the end of the year, you could try to raise your cash asset allocation to 9-10% to give you a little more buffer during the next contraction.

You will also spend less during a recession, so your two years of cash for expenses will probably stretch to 2.5 years or even longer.

In “Work Less, Live More,” Bob Clyatt pioneered the 4%/95% version of variable spending. (Look for the book at a library.)

Bob’s system withdraws 4% of your portfolio value every year, no matter what that value may be. There are no inflation adjustments, and a 4%/year withdrawal works great during bull markets. However, if the portfolio drops during a recession, you’d end up taking a huge spending cut next year.

That’s where the 95% comes in: if the market is down at the end of the year and next year’s 4% withdrawal would be an amount of money less than 95% of last year’s withdrawal amount, then cut back your spending to 95% of the previous year’s withdrawal amount. (Your withdrawals will only shrink 5%/year when the market drops.)

This means that overall you might end up withdrawing 5%-6%/year of your portfolio for a couple of years during the recession. Still, eventually, the market will recover, and your portfolio will rebuild. Bob hired a financial analysis firm to run the historical simulations (just like the 4% SWR). He brought his financial independence portfolio through the Great Recession in the same way.

Bob’s “Armageddon” solution is a temporary job— even if it’s a temporary employment agency or running errands on TaskRabbit. However, since writing WLLM, he’s rekindled his passion for art, and he’s now one of NYC’s leading sculptors. When you’re financially independent, then you’ll probably find your passion (or at least a paying hobby) that will also help you feel more productive and confident during recessions.

Mine is writing & blogging, and I could pull in at least $25K/year by working 15 hours/week. The FinCon personal-finance group is filled with hundreds of entrepreneurs doing at least that well.

Recessions during financial independence are just part of the economic cycle. Mild recessions happen once or twice a decade. More significant recessions happen once every few decades. Statistically, you may be fearing a market crash that may never occur. Here’s the crux of the 4% SWR: at least 18 times out of 20, you end up with way more money than you need.

Since we’re all (mostly) human, everybody immediately disregards the wins and zooms in on the 1 or 2 failures with laser-keen focus. We try to reduce that to “0 out of 20” by various schemes like “just one more year” or “the 3% SWR” or “living off the dividends and never touching the principal.”

However, the best way to avoid those rare failures is with some annuitized income from Social Security or an SPIA or dividends. The other winning situations will take care of themselves!

How Long do Stock Market Crashes Take to Recover?

There are three levels of crashes to consider, and in part, that determines how long recovery can take. Understand that every downturn is different, and therefore every recovery will be different.

Pullbacks are dips of 5% to 10% from a recent market high and are short-term, lasting a month on average and taking another month to retrace the losses. Pullbacks are fairly common, happening with a frequency of about one a year since World War II.

Corrections are drops between 10% and 20. They’re characterized by high volatility with rapid buying and selling as panicked investors unload their positions. These market falls tend to last four months on average and take about that long to get back to where they were.
Crashes are downturns of more than 20%. They’re almost always the prelude to a recession and can last anywhere from one to two years. Recovery can take as much as five years before recouping market losses.

Making Money During a Stock Market Crash

It’s entirely possible to make money during a crash if you’re a contrarian investor. It feels counter to what you should be doing, but experienced investors have made fortunes by reading market forces and having the risk tolerance to bet against upturns. By selling stocks short, you’re betting on a market downturn.

Another way to make money during a crash is to buy into high-quality blue-chip stocks with companies that generate real profits and attractive returns on equity, have low to moderate debt-to-equity ratios, attractive gross profit margins, and have shareholder-friendly management.

You can also employ dollar-cost averaging, which means you’re buying and selling at fixed rates and set amounts of money. It protects you from the lowest lows but limits your ability to cash in entirely on the highest highs.

There’s no sure bet for making money during every stock market crash since the factors shaping each downturn can be quite different. However, as a general rule of thumb, stocks in “defensive” sectors such as industry, finances, and health care, usually rebound well during recovery from a recession.

Another strategy is known as sector rotation. This means moving money from one stock market sector to another. For example, tech stocks tend to do well during times of high growth.

When the economy slows, stable and boring sectors like utility stocks tend to hold up better. So if you strategically move from one to the other, you may avoid large dips in one particular sector. This does go counter to the idea of sitting tight, but many people use this rotation strategy and do quite well.

You can also play defense if you’re close to retirement. Consider shifting your portfolio away from volatility by investing in bonds, dividend stocks, and reliable low-risk mutual funds with limited exposure in stocks. This slows down growth but prevents large losses in a major downturn.

Military Guide to Financial Independence

This book provides servicemembers, veterans, and their families with a critical roadmap for becoming financially independent. Topics include:
  • Military pension
  • TSP
  • Tricare Health System
  • & More

The post How Do You Survive A Stock Market Crash? appeared first on The Military Wallet.

]]>
https://themilitarywallet.com/survive-stock-market-crash/feed/ 1